Legora vs Noxtua: how they compare in 2026
This choice comes down to reach against sovereignty. Legora connects to the systems a firm already runs, reading access rights from iManage, NetDocuments or SharePoint each time and sending time entries to Intapp or Laurel, and it sells worldwide to more than 2,400 firms and teams. Noxtua keeps law and processing in Europe. It is now majority owned by the publisher C.H.BECK, draws on more than 210 million licensed documents in national editions such as Beck-Noxtua and MANZ-Noxtua, and lets an administrator choose a model category with no US provider in the chain. Legora's customers include Jones Day, Linklaters and more than half of the AmLaw 50. Noxtua serves about 30,000 users, with named counsel at EnBW and Würth, and cites German professional secrecy law for its confidentiality design. Both say client data does not train their models, Legora in its general terms and Noxtua on its security page. Firms with large document sets and global matters should pick Legora. German speaking and central European teams that need licensed national law and EU only processing should pick Noxtua.
Which one fits
Choose Legora if
- Matters live in iManage, NetDocuments or SharePoint, and you want the AI to honor those permissions every time it reads a document.
- Diligence means reviewing hundreds of documents in a grid where every cell opens to its source.
- Your work spans US law, where Legora hosts federal and state primary law updated every 24 hours, as well as European sources.
- You want contract terms you can read before the sales call, including a liability cap of at least €250,000 in the EU terms.
- Billing teams need AI assisted work to land as time entries in Intapp Time, Laurel or PointOne.
Choose Noxtua if
- Your lawyers are bound by German professional secrecy, and you want a design that cites Section 43e BRAO and Section 203 StGB.
- Processing must be able to exclude US providers altogether, which Noxtua's Athena model category does.
- Research has to rest on licensed national commentary and case law, such as Beck-Noxtua in Germany or MANZ-Noxtua in Austria.
- Your security review asks for a BSI C5 attestation or a TISAX label alongside ISO 27001 and ISO 42001.
- Administrators want to set how long chats are kept, from 8 hours to unlimited, and users want to delete chats at once.
At a glance
All 15 axes, side by side
The same grid applied to every vendor in the index, graded from public sources. Hover a grade to see what the letter means on that axis.
AI Centrality
How much of the product is actually AI. Whether the machine learning is the mechanism the buyer is paying for or a feature layered onto conventional software, and whether the vendor is specific about which is which.
Everything Legora sells is generative. The Agent plans and executes legal work across the platform's tools, Tabular Review extracts answers from each document into a grid, research answers questions across jurisdictions, and drafting runs in Word, Outlook and the built in editor. An orchestration layer handles tool routing, memory, model selection and guardrails beneath them. Without the models there is no product left to sell.
The AI is the product. Noxtua NextGen runs research, reusable Skills, matter Projects, an Editor for Word files and an Interaction layer that asks follow up questions, all built around models working over a licensed legal corpus. Administrators choose the model category. Minerva, the default, runs third party closed source frontier models in EU data centers, and Athena keeps the processing chain free of US providers. Noxtua post trains Voyage Law, a legal embedding model created by MongoDB, and self hosts LightOnOCR for document recognition and OpenAI's Whisper for transcription. Remove the models and nothing remains.
Citation Accuracy and Hallucination Disclosure
Whether the vendor publishes measured accuracy on citations and assertions, grounds output to primary sources, and says plainly what its system does when it does not know. Legal has a documented public record of fabricated citations reaching filed briefs, so an untested claim of accuracy is not evidence.
Each cell in Tabular Review expands to its reasoning and the source documents behind it, and Portal answers carry links back to the exact source. Legal research works several sources in parallel, ranks them by authority and checks each finding against primary law before the answer returns. The rebuilt research layer runs on an ontology of the law that maps how authorities rank and relate, including amendments and temporal validity, and went live in the United States on 29 October 2026. Legora says three people check every word of that data to reach 99.997 percent accuracy, and that the ontology makes the Agent 40 percent faster. US case law is updated every 24 hours. Its AI native citator, built to a standard set and audited by former publisher attorney editors, is still to come. Legora publishes its BAR benchmark of 5,161 cases across 28 practice areas, last updated in July 2026, and says it has cataloged more than 50 ways AI fails at legal research without publishing the list. No hallucination rate for the Agent's answers is published.
Research runs over a licensed corpus of more than 210 million documents, and every citation links to the relevant passage in the original text, so a reader can open the source behind each statement. Retrieval rests on Voyage Law, a legal embedding model created by MongoDB and post trained by Noxtua, and Interaction asks follow up questions when a request is unclear. No accuracy or hallucination rate for generated answers, test set or abstention behavior is published.
Autonomy and Oversight Model
What the system decides on its own, what a lawyer must approve, and whether the vendor documents where the review point sits. A tool that drafts under review and a tool that files without one are different products and different risks.
The Agent proposes a plan before it acts, carries out the work across documents, data sources and tools, checks whether it met the goal, and delivers work product into the project workspace for the lawyer's review and approval. It can also act without being asked, watching email, documents and projects and starting work when something needs attention. Tabular Review adds Mark as Reviewed, Lock Cells and Review Mode for team review, and full audit trails record every tool call, file access and agent action. ISO 42001 covers the AI management system, with human oversight named as a principle. No threshold at which the Agent stops for a person, and no route after a wrong output, is described.
Noxtua frames the product as the lawyer reviewing and deciding. Interaction asks follow up questions before the system answers, each Skill can be switched on or off, Projects keep one matter's documents together, and every citation links to the passage in the original text so a reviewer can check it. The agent plans and runs its research steps on its own. What the system may do without approval, the point at which it stops, and what happens after an answer is found wrong are not set out.
Operational and Outcome Evidence
Named, dated evidence that the product works in production at real firms or legal departments. Case studies with figures and identified customers count. Unattributed testimonials and launch announcements do not.
Legora's October 2026 Series E release puts use at more than 140,000 legal professionals at more than 2,400 firms and teams in over 80 markets, with more than half of the AmLaw 50 as customers and in house teams above 40 percent of new customers in the third quarter. Named rollouts carry dates. Jones Day took Legora firm wide across more than 2,500 lawyers in 40 offices (October 2026), Hogan Lovells Cadwalader began a pilot with more than 1,300 lawyers in 18 practice teams (October 2026), and Stoel Rives adopted it for about 350 attorneys (October 2026). Linklaters reports that 97 percent of its weekly active users worked in the Agent within a month, and that monthly active use among partners rose from 65 percent to almost 80 percent. Other named customers include White & Case, Crowell, Accor, Dentons Europe, BMW Group, Salesforce and Veolia. The customers page reports that 25 percent of users see better quality work, that experienced users save 80 percent of non billable hours weekly, and that firms bill $6.4 million more per 100 lawyers a year, without a date, sample or method for those figures.
Named customers speak on the record, among them Bernd-Michael Zinow, General Counsel of EnBW, Claudia Herger of Würth and Stanislaus Jaworski of the firm NORDEMANN, though none gives figures or dates. The law firm CMS, a co-initiator of Noxtua, remains an anchor client after leaving as an investor in the September 2026 Series C. Noxtua reports more than 30,000 users and about 100 employees. Its corpus figures, more than 210 million documents including more than 15.8 million court decisions, describe the database rather than a deployment.
Privilege and Confidentiality Posture
How client confidences are handled: attorney client privilege and work product treatment, segregation of one client matter from another, whether client data trains any model, and what the vendor commits to in writing rather than in marketing.
The general terms bar Legora from using a subscriber's confidential information to train or fine tune AI models and require the same of its subcontractors. The terms, the data processing agreement and the security measures annex are published in versions for the EU and the United States, and the annex covers least privilege access, personnel confidentiality, authorization controls and retention on customer instruction. Ethical walls and role based access are stated to keep confidential information from crossing matters or projects, on access control built on the Zanzibar authorization model, and engineers reach customer data only with the customer's written approval. Privilege and work product handling are not addressed.
The confidentiality posture engages professional secrecy in statute. Noxtua says the product is built to satisfy lawyers' confidentiality undertakings under Section 43e BRAO and Section 203 StGB. Its security page states that inputs and outputs are not used to train its AI, and that model providers neither store nor train on them under zero data retention. Separation is documented: every project is encrypted in transit and at rest under its own key, access is strictly controlled, every action is logged, and Noxtua says it has no persistent access to plaintext data. Retention is set by the administrator, and chats can be deleted at once. Certification covers AI governance as well as security. The customer agreement itself is not published, so these commitments come from the security page and FAQ rather than a contract.
UPL and Professional Responsibility Posture
Whether the vendor is clear that it supplies a tool rather than legal advice, who its audience is, and how it addresses unauthorized practice of law, competence and supervision duties, and jurisdiction limits. ABA Formal Opinion 512 is the reference point. Where the advice line is not the duty a product raises, the axis is read through the nearest professional duty it does raise: judicial conduct rules and the reviewing duty for products sold only to courts, and the duty to bill for time actually spent for products that draft time entries.
Lawyers, firms and in house teams are the buyers, and the product is described as working with lawyers rather than replacing them, with the Agent's output delivered for a lawyer's review and approval. Legora's Acceptable Use Policy, dated 4 May 2026, and clause 6.1.2 of its EU general terms state that Legora is not a law firm and does not practise law, and the Global terms warrant that its agentic tools include human in the loop review checkpoints. No treatment of competence and supervision duties and no jurisdiction limit appears in the policy, the terms or the product pages, though Legora publishes a list of supported countries.
Noxtua grounds its position in named professional law. It says the product is built to satisfy the confidentiality undertakings covering lawyers' professional secrecy, including Germany's Section 43e BRAO and Section 203 StGB, and it names its audience precisely across law firms, in house teams, auditors and tax advisers, courts and public authorities. Jurisdiction limits are structural: the product ships as national editions, access requires a jurisdiction selection, and the Swiss imprint places responsibility for using the content on the user. The product's own framing is that the lawyer reviews and decides. Competence and supervision duties are not addressed beyond that.
AI Governance and Bias Disclosure
Published governance over model behavior: who owns it inside the vendor, what is tested before release, and what is disclosed about disparate output across matter types, parties, or populations.
Legora holds ISO 42001 for its AI management system, independently audited with ongoing surveillance, and publishes what the certification covers: how AI is designed, deployed, supervised and monitored, with human oversight and structured governance as the operating principles. No internal owner of AI governance is named, no results of testing on model behavior before release are published, and nothing covers uneven output across matter types, parties or populations.
ISO 42001 certification covers Noxtua's AI management system and sits beside ISO 27001, 27017, 27018 and 9001, a BSI C5 attestation, a SOC 2 report and a TISAX label, with the trust center listing current certifications and policies. Its Chief Legal Officer, Dr. Robert Kilian, was appointed to the EU AI Office Advisory Forum in June 2026. No named internal owner of model governance, pre release testing results for model behavior, or disclosure about uneven output across matter types, parties or populations is published.
AI Safety and Data Stewardship
Retention, deletion, access control, and what happens to prompts and documents after they are processed. Whether the vendor states its subprocessors and its incident practice, or leaves the buyer to assume.
The security measures annex sets least privilege and role based access, and centrally stored logs traceable to unique usernames, with security logs kept at least 12 months. It adds data integrity signing, background checks and confidentiality agreements for staff, and retention as the customer instructs. Subscriber environments are logically separated and full production backups run every four hours. The data processing agreement has Legora report a personal data breach within 36 hours and delete or return personal data at the subscriber's choice when it ends. The subprocessor list, last updated 6 July 2026, names each provider with its purpose, data and residency, and a new subprocessor comes with 30 days to object. Penetration tests cover the full platform twice a year.
Each project is encrypted in transit and at rest under its own cryptographic key, access is strictly controlled, every action is logged, and Noxtua says it has no persistent access to plaintext data. The FAQ sets retention as an administrator choice of 8 hours, 30, 90 or 180 days, or unlimited, which is the default, and users can delete individual chats at any time with immediate effect. Model providers do not store inputs and do not train on them. A Vanta backed trust center sits at a stable URL. A full subprocessor list and a breach notification commitment are not on the open pages.
AI Liability and Recourse
What the vendor stands behind contractually when its output is wrong. Indemnities, caps, carve outs, insurance, and whether any of it is published or only reachable through a negotiated agreement.
General terms and conditions are published openly in an EU version, last updated May 2026, a version for the United States and Global terms dated September 2026. Clause 6.3.2 of the EU terms caps liability at the greater of twelve months of fees or €250,000, and clause 6.3.3 raises it for Enhanced Claims, breaches of confidentiality or the data processing agreement, to the greater of twice the fees or €500,000. The US version has the same structure in dollars, and the Global terms cap at twelve months of fees and twice the fees with no floor. Clause 5.1.1 gives an intellectual property indemnity only, clause 6.2.6 gives no warranty on output, and the Global terms exclude liability for beta features. No indemnity for third party claims arising from output or insurance position is stated.
No indemnity, liability cap, carve out, warranty on output or insurance position is published. A page titled General Terms and Conditions Noxtua NextGen holds regional imprints and privacy statements rather than terms, and the Swiss imprint says only that responsibility for using the content lies with the user. The customer agreement is reached through a sales process after a jurisdiction gated access request. The allocation of loss when output is wrong is not addressed in public.
Practice Systems Integration Depth
How deeply the product reaches into the systems legal work already lives in: document management such as iManage and NetDocuments, Word and Outlook, contract lifecycle management, matter management, e-billing, and court filing systems.
Document management systems are integrated rather than replaced. Legora reads access rights from the source system each time a user queries rather than caching them at setup, and Intapp Walls for AI and iManage Security Policy Manager enforce matter restrictions. The October 2026 ecosystem release covers reading from and saving back to iManage, NetDocuments, Box and SharePoint, and names Datasite, Intralinks, DiliTrust, Everlaw, Docusign, Ironclad, Agiloft, Slack, Salesforce and LawVu among connected systems. Laurel, Intapp Time and PointOne turn work done in Legora into time entries by client and matter. Add ins bring the Agent and playbooks into Word and Outlook, EDGAR sits among the research sources, and MCP connectors link Gemini Enterprise, Blue J and ChatGPT Enterprise. Partnerships with Sirion, Conga, Avvoka and Ansarada were announced in the second half of 2026, several rolling out in phases or in beta, and an iManage MCP server was announced as planned. Field level mappings for each connector are not documented.
The NextGen Editor works directly with Word files, so drafting can happen in Noxtua or move to Word. A Legalscape API module was added in March 2026, and US case law arrives through a Midpage data partnership announced in April 2026. Projects hold one matter each, with room for around 200 documents. No document management connector such as iManage or NetDocuments, no Outlook add in and no contract lifecycle or matter management connection is offered, and nothing describes what the Word integration moves or what an administrator configures.
Deployment Model and Data Residency
Where the software runs and where the data sits. Multi tenant cloud, single tenant, private deployment, on premises, and whether region of residence is a published option or an enterprise conversation.
Legora runs separate arrangements for the EU, the United States and Asia Pacific. Its subprocessor list sets out hosting and AI model providers by region, Microsoft, AWS and Google among them, with EU customers' data held in the EU and EEA. For Asia Pacific it separates hosting in Australia from AI model processing in the EU and Asia Pacific, with OpenAI processing in the EU. The security page says enterprise customers control where their data is stored. Storage is tiered to data sensitivity, technical teams in the EU and the United States support local clients, and subscriber environments are logically separated. The regions open to each package and the processing location for every feature are not set out in one place.
Where the software runs and where the data sits is published by model category. Minerva, the default, runs third party frontier models in EU data centers, and Athena keeps every provider in the processing chain outside the United States, so the customer's choice of category decides the jurisdiction of processing as well as storage. Hosting is in the EU, and the Swiss edition is hosted by T-Systems Schweiz AG with Noxtua GmbH in Munich as technology partner. The security page names Noxtua's certifications, including BSI C5. What else changes between editions beyond the model category is not stated.
Security Certifications and Trust Center
Independent attestation a buyer can pull without a sales call: SOC 2, ISO 27001, penetration test summaries, a trust center with current reports and named scope rather than a badge image.
ISO 27001:2022 with a yearly audit, SOC 2 Type II covering the security criteria and ISO 42001 for the AI management system are all current. The trust center at security.legora.com carries a resources section and a data flow diagram, and the security whitepapers and security measures annex are published without a gate. The security page says penetration tests run twice a year under an assume breach method, while the security measures annex of January 2025 describes them as annual. Customers can bring their own encryption keys, set retention periods and have data deleted when the contract ends. The certifying auditor is not named.
Noxtua holds a BSI C5 attestation, a SOC 2 report and a TISAX label alongside ISO 42001, 27001, 27017, 27018 and 9001, and says its controls are independently and regularly audited. The trust center is a Vanta portal at a stable URL listing current certifications and policies, a self serve route. BSI C5 is the German federal criteria for cloud computing, and TISAX is the automotive industry's information security assessment. The SOC 2 type, coverage periods, report dates and auditors are not published on the open pages.
Model Supply Chain Disclosure
Which models sit underneath, whose they are, where they run, and whether the vendor commits to telling customers when that changes. A legal buyer inherits every dependency it cannot see.
The subprocessor list, dated 6 July 2026, names Microsoft, AWS and Google for hosting, infrastructure and AI models and OpenAI for AI models, with DeepL for optional translation, Linkup Labs and Exa Labs for web results, turbopuffer for search infrastructure and Intercom for support, each with its residency. New subprocessors are announced by updating the list, with 30 days for the subscriber to object. An orchestration layer handles model selection across tasks. No model or model version is named, and nothing states which provider serves which feature.
Noxtua's model system page, updated 29 October 2026, describes two categories an administrator chooses between. Minerva, the default, gives access to international closed source frontier models from third parties, running in EU data centers, without naming the models or their providers. Athena is a category with no US provider anywhere in the processing chain. Supporting models are named with their makers: Voyage Law, created by MongoDB and post trained by Noxtua for legal content, LightOnOCR-3-1B from LightOn, and Whisper Large v3 Turbo from OpenAI, all self hosted. Noxtua says the specific models may change as the state of the art moves, and it makes no commitment to notify customers when they do.
Commercial Transparency
Whether a buyer can learn what this costs without entering a sales process: published rates, the unit being charged, what sits behind an enterprise tier, and what implementation adds.
No pricing page or rate is published, and the commercial route is a demo request. The Global terms, dated September 2026, set the charging structure: a Platform Fee plus Credits, with AI features consuming Credits (clauses 1.3 and 2.1.2), and 45 days' notice of a Platform Fee change at renewal (clause 3.1.3). The Credit terms they refer to are not linked from the site. The general terms are published openly, so the structure can be read before a sales conversation even though the figures cannot.
No pricing page, rate, unit of charge or tier structure is published. Switching to Noxtua NextGen leaves costs unchanged, full text access after the introductory phase depends on the module booked, and the Europe License, launched in February 2026, is free to existing users during its beta. Access runs through a request that first requires selecting a jurisdiction.
Firm and Practice Coverage
Who the product is actually built for. AmLaw, midlaw, small firm and solo, in house departments, government and courts, and which practice areas are supported rather than merely claimed.
Large law firms, small and mid sized firms, in house legal departments, the public sector and professional services are all served, with solution pages for M&A, litigation, banking, insurance, private equity and tax. Multi jurisdiction and cross border work are stated strengths, with research sources across Europe and federal and state law in the United States. No firm size or practice area is named as outside its scope.
Four segments have their own sections: in house legal teams, law firms, auditors and tax advisers, and courts and public authorities, the last an explicit positioning for the judiciary and public administration. Jurisdictional coverage comes as named editions for each country, spanning Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Bulgaria and Sweden, each tied to its national publisher, with US case law added as a further data source through Midpage. Practice areas are not listed beyond research, analysis and drafting, and nothing says what is not supported.
The 12 legal signals, side by side
Recorded rather than graded. These are the questions a practitioner has to answer before a tool touches a client matter, and the answers are taken from public material only.
Client Data in Training
Can material a lawyer puts into this product be used to train a model?
Under the heading Feedback, Usage Data and no training, Legora's general terms bar it from using a subscriber's confidential information to train or fine tune AI models and bar its subcontractors from doing so. Legora may use usage data to develop and improve the services, and shares it outside the company only when aggregated and anonymized. The home page and security page repeat the commitment as zero AI training on customer data.
The security page states that inputs and the product's outputs are not used to train Noxtua's AI, and that model providers neither store inputs nor train on them under zero data retention. Noxtua also says it has no persistent access to plaintext data. The commitment sits on a public security page rather than in a customer agreement, and no customer terms are published, so it is a policy statement rather than a contract term.
Prompt and Output Retention
How long does the product keep what a lawyer typed, and can that be set to zero?
Section 17 of the security measures annex, dated 31 January 2025, keeps personal data under whatever retention the subscriber instructs during the data processing agreement, and clause 11 of that agreement governs return or deletion after it ends. No default retention period or zero retention setting is published. Backups of the full production environment run every four hours, and each subscriber's environment stays logically separate.
Noxtua's FAQ lets an administrator set how long content is kept: 8 hours, 30, 90 or 180 days, or unlimited, which is the default. Users can delete individual chats at any time, and deletion takes effect immediately. Model providers do not store inputs under zero data retention. Eight hours is the shortest window offered.
Ethical Walls and Matter Segregation
Does retrieval respect the firm’s ethical walls, or can the model read across them?
Legora reads access rights from the source document system each time a user works, rather than caching them once at setup, so a lawyer sees in Legora only what iManage, NetDocuments or SharePoint already opens to them. Ethical walls are enforced through Intapp Walls for AI and iManage Security Policy Manager, and Legora's own access control, built on the Zanzibar authorization model, keeps confidential information from crossing matters or projects. Full audit trails record every tool call, file access and agent action.
Noxtua keeps its own documented separation model rather than inheriting one from a document management system. Every project is encrypted in transit and at rest under its own cryptographic key, Projects hold one matter each, access is strictly controlled, every action is logged, and Noxtua says it has no persistent access to plaintext data. The firm must keep that project structure aligned with its own walls, since no document management integration enforces permissions at query time and conflicts are not addressed as such.
Third Party Request and Subpoena Notice
If someone subpoenas the vendor for a firm’s data, does the firm hear about it first?
Either party may disclose confidential information under the general terms when law or an order of an authority, regulator or court compels it. The compelled party gives the other notice of the proceeding where the law allows and cooperates in seeking confidential treatment. The data processing agreement adds notice of any communication with a data protection authority about Legora's processing. No transparency report is published.
Noxtua makes no commitment to notify a customer of a government or law enforcement request for its data and publishes no transparency report. Its Athena model category keeps US providers out of the processing chain, which bears on which state could compel production rather than on whether the customer would be told.
Primary Law Corpus Provenance
Where does the law in this product come from, and does the vendor have the right to use it?
Legora's research page describes its corpus as publisher partnerships and official sources. Its newsroom names US federal and state primary law, hosted on Legora and updated every 24 hours, content partnerships with Wolters Kluwer's Legal and Regulatory US business and the American Law Institute, and European official sources, while the Qura acquisition adds a Swedish database of case law, legislation and regulation.
Legora says it brought in outside counsel to confirm that the court opinions it hosts are public. No license basis is stated source by source.
Sources are licensed from national legal publishers tied to the jurisdictions they serve: C.H.Beck for Germany, Poland, Czech Republic and Slovakia, MANZ for Austria, Ciela for Bulgaria and Blendow for Sweden, plus a Swiss edition and publishers including ESV, Walhalla, Nomos, Kohlhammer, Vahlen and Dike, 19 in all across eight countries. C.H.BECK has been Noxtua's majority shareholder since September 2026. Scale is given as more than 210 million documents and more than 15.8 million court decisions, and US case law arrives as an additional source through Midpage. No update schedule for this content is published.
Good Law Verification
Does the product tell you when the authority it just cited has been overruled?
Legora is building its own AI native citator on an ontology of the law. The ontology captures the hierarchy of authority, how sources relate and temporal validity, so an amended rule or an overruled case is recognized as such, and former publisher attorney editors set and audit the standard. The ontology went live in the United States on 29 October 2026, while the citator itself is still to come, with more detail promised later in 2026.
The technology comes from the Qura and Wexler acquisitions. No coverage figure or error rate is published for treatment.
Noxtua describes no treatment signal on returned authority and no check of subsequent history. Continental civil law jurisdictions do not use citators in the Anglo American sense, so the question reads differently for a vendor selling into Germany, Austria and Switzerland than for a US product, though Noxtua now adds US case law through Midpage.
Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior
What does the product do when the answer is not in the corpus?
The Agent checks whether it met the goal and loops back to adjust, and research ranks sources by authority before answering. No explicit no answer path, abstention behavior or confidence value shown to the user is described.
Noxtua describes no path for declining to answer when it cannot ground a response, and exposes no confidence signal. Its Interaction layer asks follow up questions when a request is unclear, and every citation links to its passage, which lets a reader inspect the basis of an answer that was given rather than telling them when the system found nothing.
Fabricated Citation Record
Does a public court record exist addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations in output from this product?
One decision in the AI Hallucination Cases database kept by Damien Charlotin names Legora as the tool behind a lawyer's filing. In Farhat v. Cutera, Inc. (N.D. California, 28 October 2026), the court admonished the lawyer, with no monetary or professional sanction, and no vendor dispute is recorded. Legora's research checks findings against primary law, and its Tabular Review links every answer to the document it came from.
The AI Hallucination Cases database maintained by Damien Charlotin, which tracks court decisions worldwide involving hallucinated AI content and records the tool where known, has no entry naming Noxtua. That database is weighted toward US and other common law filings, and Noxtua sells mainly into German speaking and central European jurisdictions whose decisions it covers less fully.
Bar Guidance Alignment
Has the vendor engaged in public with the ethics opinions its buyers are bound by?
Material Legora publishes on its own AI governance and ISO 42001 certification engages none of ABA Formal Opinion 512, a state bar opinion or national bar guidance on lawyers' use of AI.
Noxtua engages with the professional rules its buyers work under by citing statute: it says the product is built to satisfy lawyers' confidentiality undertakings, including Section 43e of the German Federal Code for Lawyers and Section 203 of the German Criminal Code. Those are statutes on professional secrecy rather than bar or ethics opinions, and no opinion from a bar association or ethics body is addressed. The engagement covers German law, although the product ships in national editions across eight countries.
Billing and Fee Posture
Does the vendor address what happens to the bill when the work takes an hour instead of six?
Law firms and in house teams buy the product. Integrations announced between August and October 2026 with Intapp Time, Laurel and PointOne turn each task a lawyer completes in Legora into a time entry by client and matter, giving firms a record of AI assisted work for billing. The customers page also reports 80 percent of non billable hours saved weekly by experienced users and $6.4 million in additional billing per 100 lawyers a year. Legora offers no guidance on how firms should bill or disclose AI assisted work to clients.
Noxtua offers no guidance on billing, fees or client disclosure and no record of AI assisted work by matter for fee purposes. It makes no time savings or efficiency claims either, framing the product around precision, verifiability and permissibility rather than hours saved.
Outside Counsel Guideline Readiness
Can a firm get this vendor through a client’s AI clause without a bespoke negotiation?
Legora publishes its subprocessor list by region, last updated 6 July 2026, naming Microsoft, AWS, Google and OpenAI as AI model and hosting providers with their purpose, data categories and residency, and offers email updates. Its general terms, data processing agreement, security measures annex and acceptable use policy are published without a gate. No client facing consent or notice pack is offered, and trust center documents come through a request.
A trust center sits at a stable URL, reachable without a sales conversation, listing current certifications and policies. The security page names BSI C5, a SOC 2 report, TISAX, ISO 42001, 27001, 27017, 27018 and 9001. The model system page sets out the two model categories, with the self hosted supporting models named by maker, while the frontier models behind the default category are not named. No formal subprocessor list and no consent or notification material for clients are published on the open pages.
Court Disclosure Support
If a judge’s standing order requires an AI disclosure, can the product produce one?
Full audit trails record every tool call, file access and agent action, Tabular Review cells link to their source documents, and Portal answers cite the exact source. No export for each document records the model used and the human verification, and no court disclosure template is offered.
Several elements of a disclosure record are available. Every action is logged, every citation links to the relevant passage in the original text, and Projects keep one matter's documents and work together. Sources relied on and the steps taken can therefore be recovered. No export for each document covering the model used, the sources retrieved and human verification together is offered, and human verification is not recorded as such.
The questions both sides leave open
Derived from the records above rather than written, so it cannot favor either vendor. Take these into both conversations and ask each side the same question.
- Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior
Product updates
The latest logged changes from each vendor, newest first, each linked to its source.
Legora
-
Product / capability
Ontological Legal Research is now live in the US, after Legora described the approach in September.
Source -
Product / capability
Legora launched Intake, available now in Slack.
Source -
Product / capability
Legora released Skills to all customers: Markdown instruction files, which can bundle templates and examples, that teach the Legora Agent a team's standards, processes and preferences.
Source
Noxtua
-
Privilege / confidentiality
Noxtua added auto delete for chats and projects.
Source -
Privilege / confidentiality
The Model System support article sets out the data path for the new Frontier (Minerva) category: the closed source model is accessed through Deutsche Telekom's T Cloud Public over an encrypted, isolated connection into a dedicated Google processing environment in an EU data center, under a data processing agreement.
Source -
Model / architecture
Noxtua shipped the Noxtua Model System, a model picker in Chat, Matrix and the Word and Outlook add ins that lets users choose between base model categories and switch at any time, including mid conversation.
Source
In summary
Legora
Legora is a Stockholm AI workspace for law firms and in house teams, used by more than 140,000 legal professionals at more than 2,400 firms and teams, including Jones Day and Linklaters. Its Agent plans and runs multistep work, Tabular Review turns document sets into a grid with a source behind every cell, and add ins bring it into Word and Outlook. According to the AI Legal Index, Legora reads access rights from the firm's document system each time a user works, and its general terms bar training on customer data. Linklaters reports that 97 percent of its weekly active users worked in the Agent within a month. The main caveat is research, where the US ontology went live only in October 2026 and its own citator is still to come.
Noxtua
Noxtua is a Berlin legal AI, majority owned by the publisher C.H.BECK since September 2026, sold to law firms, in house teams, tax advisers, courts and public authorities in German speaking and central European markets. Its NextGen product combines research over more than 210 million licensed documents, reusable Skills, matter Projects and an Editor for Word files, shipped as national editions such as Beck-Noxtua. The AI Legal Index notes that administrators choose between Minerva, which runs third party frontier models in EU data centers, and Athena, which keeps US providers out of the chain. Named counsel at EnBW and Würth speak for it. The main caveat is that its customer terms, including liability, are reached only through sales.
Questions buyers ask
How does Legora compare to Noxtua?
Legora is a connected AI workspace used worldwide, strongest where a firm's matters live in iManage, NetDocuments or SharePoint and span many document sets. Noxtua is a European legal AI built on licensed national publisher content, strongest where professional secrecy and EU only processing decide the purchase. Both handle research and drafting, and Legora adds large scale tabular review and client portals. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 3, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
How much do Legora and Noxtua cost?
Legora and Noxtua both sell by quote. Legora's Global terms charge a platform fee plus credits that the AI features consume, with 45 days' notice of a platform fee change at renewal. Noxtua prices by the modules booked, says moving to NextGen leaves costs unchanged, and offers its Europe License free to existing users during the beta. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 3, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Do Legora and Noxtua train their AI on client data?
Both say no. Legora's general terms bar it and its subprocessors from training or fine tuning AI models on customer content. Noxtua's security page says inputs and outputs are not used to train its AI and that model providers neither store nor train on them, a policy statement rather than a contract term. Noxtua also lets administrators set retention from 8 hours to unlimited. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 3, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Where do Legora and Noxtua process client data?
Legora runs separate EU, US and Asia Pacific arrangements on Microsoft, AWS and Google, keeps EU customers' data in the EU and EEA, and lets enterprise customers control where data is stored. Noxtua runs its default models in EU data centers, and its Athena category keeps every US provider out of the processing chain, while the Swiss edition is hosted by T-Systems Schweiz. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 3, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Which one is better for legal research?
It depends on the jurisdiction. Noxtua's national editions draw on licensed publisher content across eight countries, with more than 15.8 million court decisions, and every citation links to its passage. Legora hosts US federal and state primary law updated every 24 hours, moved its US research onto an ontology of the law in October 2026, and adds European official sources, with its own citator still to come. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 3, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Neither vendor paid for inclusion, placement or a grade, and neither reviewed this page before it published. Everything on it comes from public material on the dates shown. How the index grades.
Neither vendor publishes a price figure or an accuracy rate for its answers. Noxtua publishes no customer terms, so its liability position and the models behind its default category are points to settle in the order. For Legora, the open points are the credit price and which integrations and research jurisdictions a package includes.