SimpleLegal vs Tonkean LegalWorks: how they compare in 2026
SimpleLegal and Tonkean LegalWorks both serve in house legal operations, but they sit at opposite ends of a matter. Tonkean works at the front door. Requests arrive through Slack, Microsoft Teams, email or a portal, its AI Front Door answers simple questions, and LegalGPT classifies the rest. Agents produce NDAs and statements of work, while conflict waivers, intellectual property questions and outside counsel engagements go to the right lawyer. SimpleLegal, part of Onit, works where the money is. It runs electronic billing, matters, vendors, budgets and accruals, and SimpleReview reads billing narratives to flag lines that fixed rules miss before approved invoices go to accounts payable. The two connect, since Tonkean lists SimpleLegal among its legal integrations. They price differently: Tonkean by monthly tracked user, SimpleLegal by quoted subscription with published storage overages. On data, Onit's product terms allow training its AI on customer data, while Tonkean's published terms say nothing about training. A department fixing intake and triage fits Tonkean. A department controlling outside counsel spend fits SimpleLegal.
Which one fits
Choose SimpleLegal if
- Outside counsel invoices are the main job. SimpleLegal handles electronic billing, timekeeper rates, billing rules, line adjustments, approvals and payment tracking in one place.
- Rules alone flag the wrong lines. SimpleReview reads billing narratives in context, so a word like postage is judged by the work described rather than the keyword.
- Finance needs approved invoices in its own system. The REST API creates vendors, matters and payments and sends approved invoices to accounts payable or an ERP.
- You want a named result from a peer. Instacart reports savings of about 10 percent of identified legal spend and outside counsel paid in 15 days or less on average.
- Remedies should be in the contract. Onit warrants the subscription against its description, refunds unused fees if a failure is not cured, and defends qualifying intellectual property claims.
Choose Tonkean LegalWorks if
- Requests arrive everywhere. Tonkean takes them from Slack, Microsoft Teams, email or a branded portal and routes them by type and risk.
- Routine paper should not reach a lawyer. Agents handle NDAs and statements of work automatically, while conflict waivers and outside counsel engagements go to the right person.
- Legal sits on a stack of other systems. LegalWorks connects to Ironclad, TeamConnect and SimpleLegal, and to DocuSign, Adobe Sign, SharePoint, Salesforce, ServiceNow, Coupa and SAP.
- Your security team wants hosting choices. Tonkean offers a shared AWS cloud, a dedicated single tenant cloud, or hosting in your own AWS, Azure or Google Cloud environment.
- You pay for use, not seats. Charging is per monthly tracked user, a person who submits, opens, replies or approves in a month, averaged over the year.
At a glance
All 15 axes, side by side
The same grid applied to every vendor in the index, graded from public sources. Hover a grade to see what the letter means on that axis.
AI Centrality
How much of the product is actually AI. Whether the machine learning is the mechanism the buyer is paying for or a feature layered onto conventional software, and whether the vendor is specific about which is which.
SimpleReview supplies AI invoice review within SimpleLegal's broader matter and spending system. Machine learning and natural language processing interpret billing narratives, identify errors and recommend attention to lines that conventional rules can miss. The model distinguishes identical words describing different work, such as shipping a package versus preparing litigation involving the shipping company. Intelligent Invoice Workflows separately apply configured billing rules and route approvals, and duplicate invoice and line item detection, added in November 2025, is not described as AI. Matter intake, budgets, accrual reminders, vendor records and reporting remain useful without AI. The SimpleLegal product page now leads with billing and matter management, while SimpleReview's role and its training rights are set out in Onit's product terms. Unity is an upgrade destination with additional AI functions such as Spend Agent and Ask Unity, rather than an automatic entitlement of every SimpleLegal account.
AI Front Door reads plain language requests, LegalGPT sorts and classifies unstructured requests, and packaged agents handle NDA generation and contract work. Underneath is a process orchestration platform built without code, with forms, rules, approval chains, dashboards and integrations, sold in the same form to procurement and IT. The published subprocessor table lists Microsoft Azure for AI LLM engine services, OpenAI for AI and machine learning features and Google Cloud for OCR, and marks all three opt in, so a customer that does not opt in gets an orchestration platform with no model behind it.
Citation Accuracy and Hallucination Disclosure
Whether the vendor publishes measured accuracy on citations and assertions, grounds output to primary sources, and says plainly what its system does when it does not know. Legal has a documented public record of fabricated citations reaching filed briefs, so an untested claim of accuracy is not evidence.
SimpleReview evaluates submitted invoice narratives and flags particular billing lines for review. Its machine learning and language processing add context to fixed billing rules, with a postage example illustrating why a keyword alone can produce a false flag. Invoice detail and summary PDFs remain accessible through the API, and reviewers can inspect the underlying financial record. No current test set, false-positive rate or independently reproducible accuracy result accompanies this explanation. A complete account of how every AI flag links to its supporting rule is also unavailable. Onit's AI terms warn that output can be inaccurate, biased or hallucinated and place verification with the customer; the illustrative example is not an evaluation.
The AI Front Door trawls the data sources the customer has given it access to and generates a document if one does not already exist, and agents draw on connected enterprise systems. The LegalWorks page, the security page, the pricing page, the DPA and the customer terms publish no accuracy figure, test set, evaluation, error rate or method description, and no output is presented with a traceable citation to the source record it came from. The agreement says Tonkean does not warrant that the Platform will meet the customer's requirements or expectations, including with respect to any actions or outcomes of use of Tonkean's A.I. Bot. Nothing on those pages addresses hallucination. Tonkean also publishes product documentation at docs.tonkean.com and an AI handbook.
Autonomy and Oversight Model
What the system decides on its own, what a lawyer must approve, and whether the vendor documents where the review point sits. A tool that drafts under review and a tool that files without one are different products and different risks.
SimpleReview identifies suspect billing entries while the department's reviewers make final decisions on the flagged lines. Intelligent Invoice Workflows handle a different layer: customers can configure rules to highlight, reject or adjust entries and build approval routes for their teams. Progress indicators and timestamps show invoice status, and approvers can see why they were included. Instacart describes adding a second approver when an invoice includes work another colleague commissioned. These controls provide an actual review surface and responsibility assignment. The product does not specify an AI confidence threshold that halts processing, a universal approval requirement for every automatic adjustment, or a model-error escalation and rollback procedure.
Simple requests such as NDAs and statements of work are handled automatically, and urgency is identified on every incoming request. Complex matters, including conflict waivers, intellectual property questions and outside counsel engagements, are routed to the right person or practice group. Approval paths and risk tiers follow the department's policy, intake forms adapt to risk level and matter type, and every action and approval is logged. The thresholds are set by the customer, and no default is published. No confidence signal, abstention state or behavior on a misclassified request is described.
Operational and Outcome Evidence
Named, dated evidence that the product works in production at real firms or legal departments. Case studies with figures and identified customers count. Unattributed testimonials and launch announcements do not.
Instacart's case study identifies Veronica Yu, Legal Process Manager, and describes the move from manual invoice tracking to a central repository with practice group reporting. It attributes savings of about 10 percent of identified legal spending to SimpleLegal, reports payment to outside counsel in 15 days or less on average, and contrasts two or three clicks for executive reports with more than two hours previously. Yu also describes assigning a second approver for work commissioned by a colleague. The case has no dated measurement window, sample size or calculation method. Onit's SimpleLegal page adds aggregate claims of 860,000 matters managed, $5.2 billion of legal spend processed a year and more than 14,000 annual user logins, without a method. None of these figures isolates the separate contribution of SimpleReview's AI.
The LegalWorks page shows twenty enterprise logos, including Google, Lenovo, AbbVie, Workday, Cisco and Intuit, under the heading trusted by enterprises like; it is the same strip used across the site, not a LegalWorks customer list. The headline figures have no attribution or basis: 50 percent shorter cycle times, 99 percent of customers reporting higher adoption, 30 employee hours saved weekly, 7.7 billion steps automated a year. Two of three attributed quotes come from procurement. The Head of Global Procurement at Semrush gives the only hard figure, a cycle time falling from 19 days to 10, and the other is from the Head of Procurement at Cockroach Labs. The legal quote, from Mary O'Carroll, described as former President of CLOC and Head of Legal Operations at Google, concerns Tonkean in general rather than LegalWorks. Tonkean also publishes a customer showcase.
Privilege and Confidentiality Posture
How client confidences are handled: attorney client privilege and work product treatment, segregation of one client matter from another, whether client data trains any model, and what the vendor commits to in writing rather than in marketing.
The services agreement treats Customer Data as confidential, limits access to personnel and agents with a need to know, and requires reasonable protective care. SimpleReview's specific terms nevertheless permit analysis, AI training, benchmarking and improvement using that data. Externally shared results generally must be anonymized, aggregated or not recoverable, but named timekeepers, classifications, firms, rates, matter types and other law-firm data have a benchmarking exception. The API limits matter and invoice lists to records accessible to its user. The agreement provides 30 days for export after termination, followed by deletion under the applicable retention policy. Privilege preservation, AI context isolation and precise third-party model retention remain unresolved.
The LegalWorks governance section offers an audit trail of all actions and approvals, presented as helping preserve attorney client privilege, plus role based access control, ethical walls, item level retention and legal holds. The customer terms say User Content is not information acquired by Tonkean, which takes customer content out of the contractual confidentiality duty and refers it to the Security section, where Tonkean says it cannot fully ensure or warrant the security and privacy of User Content or personal information. Tonkean has no right in User Content beyond the minimum needed to run the Platform and may not use it for any other purpose, and the DPA bars Tonkean from deriving rights or benefits from Personal Information.
UPL and Professional Responsibility Posture
Whether the vendor is clear that it supplies a tool rather than legal advice, who its audience is, and how it addresses unauthorized practice of law, competence and supervision duties, and jurisdiction limits. ABA Formal Opinion 512 is the reference point. Where the advice line is not the duty a product raises, the axis is read through the nearest professional duty it does raise: judicial conduct rules and the reviewing duty for products sold only to courts, and the duty to bill for time actually spent for products that draft time entries.
Onit's services agreement expressly states that the company is not a law firm and offers no legal advice, recommendations or representation. SimpleReview's own product terms repeat that it supplies no legal advice and disclaim guarantees for invoice-review results. Customers must review AI output and obtain professional advice when appropriate. The intended users are corporate legal and legal operations teams managing matters, firms and spending, with finance and submitting firms participating in the workflow. AI use is restricted to legitimate internal business purposes, and materially consequential decisions about individuals are prohibited. The terms do not map these controls to lawyers' competence duties, individual licensing jurisdictions or a client-consent workflow.
The customer terms state that the Service provides ideas, suggestions, analyses and other data for informational purposes only and not as advice, and disclaim responsibility for any information provided by the Service. The agreement carrying that sentence is drafted for a business management platform and was last updated May 2019, before LegalWorks and every agent now sold. The marketing describes agents that handle complex contract analysis and negotiation strategies, and an AI Front Door that answers employees' legal questions directly. The buyer is a corporate legal department and the requesters are its own employees, so there is no consumer surface. No rule of professional conduct or bar guidance is named, no jurisdiction limit is stated, and nothing covers how a legal team supervises an agent that answers a business question without a lawyer seeing it.
AI Governance and Bias Disclosure
Published governance over model behavior: who owns it inside the vendor, what is tested before release, and what is disclosed about disparate output across matter types, parties, or populations.
The AI contract identifies inaccurate, biased and hallucinated output as risks, assigns review responsibility to customers and prohibits high-risk decisions that materially affect individuals. Sensitive inputs and publication of benchmarks require prior written approval. These are use restrictions and risk statements, rather than a SimpleReview testing or model-governance program. SimpleReview learns from historical billing information and customer data, which makes differences across matter types, timekeeper classifications and firm billing practices relevant to its recommendations. No named accountable model owner, release acceptance tests, subgroup performance findings or recurring bias-monitoring procedure is specified for that product. Onit's broader AI commentary stays general and does not set out those operational controls for invoice review.
Tonkean's agents act on simple requests without a lawyer involved. No responsible AI page, principles statement, named owner for model behavior or testing regime before release appears on the LegalWorks, security or pricing pages. Nothing addresses bias, including whether triage and classification perform evenly across request types, business units or languages, although the product's core job is deciding which requests are simple enough to resolve without a lawyer. The security page covers information security, not model governance. The navigation includes an AI handbook page headed with questions about what an agent is and when one counts as an enterprise agent.
AI Safety and Data Stewardship
Retention, deletion, access control, and what happens to prompts and documents after they are processed. Whether the vendor states its subprocessors and its incident practice, or leaves the buyer to assume.
Onit's data processing addendum requires confidentiality, access controls, breach notification and cooperation, with return or destruction of personal data on the customer's written request subject to legal exceptions. Its security annex covers differentiated access, encrypted transfers, activity logs, separation of production and testing, and multifactor remote access. The subprocessor register separates the SimpleLegal services and names hosting, PDF processing, authentication, support and analytics providers. The agreement allows a 30-day export period after termination, then deletion according to the current retention policy, with backup and lawful recordkeeping exceptions. No fixed purge schedule for every copy or model-processing log is stated. SimpleReview's training permission also limits any inference of ephemeral processing.
The customer controls retention in detail, setting item level policies down to individual fields so data is kept only as long as a process needs. The DPA adds that within 60 days of termination Tonkean will delete or return all Personal Data at the customer's choice and delete existing copies, keeping one copy only where law requires. Access control is described as comprehensive and role based across data access and process creation, and encryption is AES-256 at rest and in transit. Audit logs that cannot be repudiated record all edits and processed transactions. The subprocessor list is published, naming each provider, its function and its country. Tonkean commits to notify without undue delay after becoming aware of a Data Incident, with no stated deadline, and the same clause bars the customer from publishing anything identifying Tonkean about an incident without prior written approval unless legally compelled.
AI Liability and Recourse
What the vendor stands behind contractually when its output is wrong. Indemnities, caps, carve outs, insurance, and whether any of it is published or only reachable through a negotiated agreement.
The services agreement provides a warranty that the subscription will substantially match its functional description and a remedy process requiring notice within 30 days of discovering noncompliance. Uncured failures can lead to termination and a refund of unused fees. Onit also defends qualifying third-party intellectual-property claims, subject to exclusions for customer data, combinations, customer specifications and continued use after notice. Ordinary liability is capped at 12 months of fees under the relevant order; the intellectual-property indemnity is excluded from that cap. AI features and outputs are supplied as is, with no accuracy warranty or standard AI service levels. SimpleReview separately disclaims performance guarantees, leaving incorrect billing judgments outside a specific output warranty.
Total liability is capped at the fees actually paid in the three months before the claim arose. Excluded damages are broad, covering loss or corruption of data, lost profits and pure economic loss. No indemnity runs to the customer. The only intellectual property remedy is that Tonkean may, at its discretion, procure a license, modify the Platform or terminate and refund the remaining period, and the agreement says no other rights or remedies accrue. The indemnity that exists runs from customer to Tonkean. The warranty is to repair or replace material errors that prevent ordinary use, and expressly does not extend to any actions or outcomes of use of Tonkean's A.I. Bot. No insurance position is published. The agreement was last updated in May 2019, before the 2026 agentic product it governs, and mentions AI once, to disclaim it.
Practice Systems Integration Depth
How deeply the product reaches into the systems legal work already lives in: document management such as iManage and NetDocuments, Word and Outlook, contract lifecycle management, matter management, e-billing, and court filing systems.
SimpleLegal's REST API moves legal and finance records between systems. Integrations can create vendors, users, matters and payments; retrieve invoices and cost codes; update matter and vendor fields; and send approved invoices to accounts payable or an ERP for payment. The reference describes token authentication, JSON responses, pagination and field filters. Matter creation must satisfy the selected or default template, and integrations must retain the returned record because template rules can change submitted values. A matter flag controls availability to an installed IPfolio integration. Invoice responses include line allocations, currency conversion and approval status; payment creation can mark the invoice paid. This supplies object-level configuration and transaction direction, beyond connector names.
The legal connections are Ironclad for contract lifecycle management, TeamConnect for matter management and SimpleLegal for legal spend, plus DocuSign and Adobe Sign for signatures and SharePoint for documents. The wider set includes Salesforce, ServiceNow, JIRA, Slack, Microsoft Teams, email, Coupa and SAP, and the product is designed as an orchestration layer across them rather than a system to migrate into. Contracts sync from CLM to electronic signature, approvals run through email and chat, data is pulled from billing systems, and work is coordinated with outside counsel platforms. The LegalWorks page does not say what a legal team must set up, which fields map, or what an integration requires. Tonkean also publishes an integration library and developer documentation.
Deployment Model and Data Residency
Where the software runs and where the data sits. Multi tenant cloud, single tenant, private deployment, on premises, and whether region of residence is a published option or an enterprise conversation.
SimpleLegal operates as a hosted service. Onit's subprocessor register assigns SimpleLegal, SimpleReview and Unity to Amazon Web Services in the United States, including AWS PDF processing, and Counsel Exchange, the law firm portal that replaced CounselGO, is hosted in the United States. Affinda converts portal PDFs in Australia, while Auth0 supplies authentication in the United States. The register also lists global Onit service affiliates and an all platform OpenAI service with United States and worldwide processing, so some operations may run abroad even though core hosting sits in the United States. Germany hosting options belong to a separate Onit platform table and cannot be assumed for SimpleLegal. For this product, Onit describes no customer operated deployment, no dedicated tenancy and no feature by feature map of inference locations.
Three options are described: a multi tenant public cloud on AWS managed by Tonkean, a single tenant dedicated cloud on AWS also managed by Tonkean, and self hosting in the customer's own AWS, Azure or Google Cloud environment. Multi tenant hosting is included in the price, while dedicated, customer cloud and on premise options come on the enterprise plan at extra cost. The DPA lists every subprocessor in the United States except Tonkean Israel Ltd., and Schedule 2 incorporates the 2021 Standard Contractual Clauses with UK and Swiss addenda for transfers out of the EEA. No region choice is published for the managed offering, and no page says where data is stored as distinct from processed.
Security Certifications and Trust Center
Independent attestation a buyer can pull without a sales call: SOC 2, ISO 27001, penetration test summaries, a trust center with current reports and named scope rather than a badge image.
Onit's security material describes independent audits against SSAE-18 SOC 2 Type 2 and other security standards. It also describes encrypted transport, daily backups, restricted project access, managed virtual private clouds, hardened systems, monitoring and logged administrative activity. The data processing addendum adds contractual access, transfer and audit obligations. The trust center offers assurance reports on request. Onit does not give SimpleLegal's audit coverage period, auditor or system scope. Consequently, the corporate audit statement does not identify which SimpleReview components or AI providers were examined. Separate attestations for sibling products do not settle that question, and HIPAA wording alone is not a signed BAA.
The security page states SOC 2 Type 2 compliance, independently audited under the AICPA Trust Services Criteria for security, availability and confidentiality. ISO/IEC 27001:2022 is stated as achieved, and a HIPAA compliance page sits alongside. No auditor is named and no audit period or report date is given for either. The reports are limited to existing customers, who are invited to ask the team for the latest one, and there is no trust portal. The badges shown are the certification marks themselves.
Model Supply Chain Disclosure
Which models sit underneath, whose they are, where they run, and whether the vendor commits to telling customers when that changes. A legal buyer inherits every dependency it cannot see.
The subprocessor register, updated 17 August 2026, names OpenAI as an all platform provider for natural language or code generation, processed in the United States and worldwide. Its SimpleLegal section names AWS PDF processing, Affinda for PDF conversion and Maven AGI for support questions, alongside hosting and authentication services. The Counsel Exchange table, now SimpleLegal's law firm portal, lists Google Cloud including Gemini for Spend Agent and other Onit AI agents and features. SimpleReview itself is described as machine learning and natural language processing for invoice context, without model versions or a precise assignment of each provider to that feature. The services agreement lets Onit improve, replace or deprecate models or prompts without materially reducing core functionality. Subprocessor objection rights do not amount to advance notice of every model version change.
Schedule 1 of the published DPA lists each subprocessor with its service and country: Microsoft Azure for AI LLM engine services, OpenAI, LLC for AI and machine learning features, and Google Cloud Platform for OCR, all in the United States and each marked opt in. It also lists AWS for cloud storage, Elastic.co for the hosted index database, SendGrid for email and Tonkean Israel Ltd. as an affiliate. Tonkean must give notice before authorizing a new subprocessor, the customer has seven days to object, and an unresolved objection allows termination of the affected services. Azure and OpenAI are providers, not models, and no model or version is named.
Commercial Transparency
Whether a buyer can learn what this costs without entering a sales process: published rates, the unit being charged, what sits behind an enterprise tier, and what implementation adds.
The core SimpleLegal subscription requires an order and quoted scope. Product terms, updated 6 May 2026, include 1 TB across production, development and test environments unless the order differs, with additional storage charged at $600 per month per TB. A separate Legal Vendor Billing arrangement may charge submitting firms annually according to invoice submissions, using prior activity and an estimate for a new connection. The customer subscription can change if those vendor fees are unpaid or spending falls below expectations. Implementation follows a statement of work, with reimbursable expenses. Default annual renewals require 45 days' notice, and AI fair use enforcement can add overages after warning. Onit gives no core user prices, standard implementation amounts or SimpleReview allowances.
Charging is per Monthly Tracked User, defined precisely: a unique person who in a calendar month submits a form, opens a workspace app, submits or replies to an item in Slack or Teams, sends or replies to a Tonkean email, or clicks a button or updates an item. Tonkean says these are not named seats or a count of records, that a counted person's actions that month are unlimited, and that billing uses the average across the subscription year so busy months even out. A quote has three parts: the platform with unlimited workflows and connectors, the user volume, and optional deployment and services. Hosting and support tiers are itemized. No price, band, minimum or term is published, and every route ends in a scheduled call.
Firm and Practice Coverage
Who the product is actually built for. AmLaw, midlaw, small firm and solo, in house departments, government and courts, and which practice areas are supported rather than merely claimed.
SimpleLegal serves corporate legal departments that need electronic billing, matter management, vendor coordination and reporting in one system. Intake templates, tasks, practice area assignments, budgets, accruals and cost allocations support department administration across internal and external matters. Finance teams receive approved invoices and payment information, while firms submit bills and collaborate through Counsel Exchange, which replaced CounselGO on 17 September 2026. Onit says the product supports more than 170 currencies, serves more than 550 corporate legal departments and manages 860,000 matters. Onit distinguishes this offering from its more configurable OnitX enterprise platform and offers an in place upgrade to Unity that ends with SimpleLegal's retirement, without a set date. Supported practice workflows are administrative and financial; Onit sets no detailed jurisdiction, language or organization size boundaries, and legal research is not its stated function.
The segment is corporate and government in house legal departments at enterprise scale, with material addressed separately to employees raising requests, the legal team, and colleagues in procurement, sales and IT. Coverage is expressed as request types rather than practice groups: NDAs, statements of work, contract review, conflict waivers, intellectual property questions, outside counsel engagement, legal mailroom, email triage and general matter intake. Customers are drawn from Fortune 500 and Fortune 200 enterprises. Nothing addresses use by law firms, no minimum department size is given, no jurisdiction or language coverage is published, and no request type is named as unsuitable for automated handling.
The 12 legal signals, side by side
Recorded rather than graded. These are the questions a practitioner has to answer before a tool touches a client matter, and the answers are taken from public material only.
Client Data in Training
Can material a lawyer puts into this product be used to train a model?
Onit's product terms, updated 6 May 2026, let it use customer data for analysis, training its AI engines, benchmarking and improvement of its offerings. Results shared externally generally must be anonymized, aggregated or not recoverable, but the benchmarking exception includes timekeeper names, classifications, firm names, rates, matter types and other law firm data. The services agreement, updated 15 October 2026, also permits aggregated and anonymized product improvement, and it bars third party model providers from using input to train models for others.
That narrower restriction does not erase the product terms' permission. The terms give no standard customer opt out from that training right.
No published material mentions training either way, and the agreement grants no right to improve anything using customer content. The customer terms say Tonkean has no right in User Content beyond the minimum needed to run the Platform and may not use it for any other purpose. The DPA adds that Tonkean may not have, derive or exercise any rights or benefits from Personal Information processed for the customer and may use it only for the purposes for which it was provided.
Both would exclude training by their terms, and neither names it. The DPA also lists making Personal Data fully anonymous among permitted processing purposes, without saying what may then be done with the result. The LLM subprocessors, Microsoft Azure and OpenAI, are marked opt in, so a customer that does not opt in has no model processing its content at all.
Prompt and Output Retention
How long does the product keep what a lawyer typed, and can that be set to zero?
Customer records remain in the service for the subscription, followed by a 30 day export period after termination. Deletion then follows Onit's current retention policy, without a fixed deadline covering all copies. Backup, legal and reasonable internal recordkeeping exceptions remain. The data processing addendum provides return or destruction on written instruction, subject to legal exceptions. The services agreement says Onit has no obligation to retain or recreate output unless the feature expressly supports retention and it is enabled. That is not a promise that prompts, outputs, derived training data or provider logs are immediately purged.
The security page says item level policies let a customer set retention periods down to individual fields, so sensitive data is kept only as long as each process needs. The DPA covers the end: within 60 days of termination Tonkean will delete or return all Personal Data at the customer's choice and delete existing copies, keeping one copy only where law authorizes or requires it for legal claims. No zero retention option is stated for prompts and model outputs, and nothing distinguishes keeping a request record from keeping the model exchange that resolved it. No default period is published for a customer that configures nothing.
Ethical Walls and Matter Segregation
Does retrieval respect the firm’s ethical walls, or can the model read across them?
The API returns only matters and invoices accessible to the authenticated API user. Its log interface distinguishes administrator, finance, power-user and filtered roles, while matter configuration includes an assigned lead and approval responsibility. An IPfolio availability flag controls whether an installed connection can access a particular matter. These are SimpleLegal's own access and sharing controls, requiring administration within the platform.
Nothing describes inheritance of an external document system's ethical walls, or whether every SimpleReview training and inference context follows the same matter restrictions.
The LegalWorks governance section lists comprehensive role-based access control and ethical walls together as a single bullet, alongside full audit logs and item-level retention, and the security page describes RBAC in general terms as ensuring every permission from data access through process creation is secured. Neither states how a wall is defined, at what level it operates, whether it applies to matters, clients or business units, who administers it, or what a walled user sees.
Tenant separation is published, with a single-tenant dedicated cloud and a self-hosted option, and it separates customers from each other rather than matters within one legal department. Tonkean also publishes product documentation at docs.tonkean.com.
Third Party Request and Subpoena Notice
If someone subpoenas the vendor for a firm’s data, does the firm hear about it first?
The services agreement requires reasonable advance notice of legally compelled disclosure when the law allows it, together with cooperation at the customer's expense to obtain confidential treatment. Disclosed material remains confidential between the parties. The data processing addendum adds prompt notice of governmental or third-party requests for personal data unless notification is prohibited. These contractual obligations are more specific than the privacy policy's discretionary notice wording.
No regular transparency report establishes actual request volumes, contested demands or the frequency with which notice has been legally barred.
The DPA says that where law, a court or a government authority requires processing, Tonkean will tell the customer of the requirement first, unless prohibited on important grounds of public interest. Schedule 2 Part 4 goes further for transfers across borders. If a government authority seeks access, Tonkean will tell it the customer has not authorized disclosure and that demands should go to the customer. It will use commercially reasonable legal means to challenge the demand and notify the customer as soon as possible after any emergency access.
Once every twelve months, on written request, Tonkean will tell the customer what types of binding legal demands for personal data it has received, including national security orders and any process under section 702 of the US Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. Tonkean also commits to resist bulk surveillance requests. The reporting is available on request rather than published.
Primary Law Corpus Provenance
Where does the law in this product come from, and does the vendor have the right to use it?
SimpleReview works with legal billing narratives and historical invoice information, rather than a stated primary-law research collection. Its contextual analysis distinguishes similar words used for different billing tasks, and its terms authorize customer-data use for training and benchmarking. Those terms establish a use permission for supplied business records, not provenance or licensing of cases, statutes or commentary.
No jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction primary-law inventory, publisher license or legal-source update cadence is specified. The presence of matter and practice-area fields does not make the platform a case-law database.
The material the models read is the customer's own. The AI Front Door searches the data sources the customer gives it access to, and agents draw on connected systems including contract lifecycle management, billing, document stores and chat. The product retrieves no primary law, published precedent or licensed third party data, and none is named on the LegalWorks page, the platform navigation, the security page, the pricing page, the DPA or the customer terms.
Good Law Verification
Does the product tell you when the authority it just cited has been overruled?
SimpleLegal evaluates invoices, timekeepers, spending and matter administration. Its review can identify billing issues and compare entries with configured rules, while the API exposes financial records and their approval state. None of these functions determines whether a cited judicial decision has been reversed or negatively treated. No citator connection, authority-status indicator or automated subsequent-history procedure is specified for SimpleReview.
Users managing a litigation matter still need a separate legal-research process to establish the current status of an authority used in legal advice or a filing.
LegalWorks routes and resolves internal legal requests and generates operational documents such as NDAs and statements of work. No case, statute or regulation is surfaced to a user at any point in the published workflow, and nothing addresses checking authority for subsequent history.
Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior
What does the product do when the answer is not in the corpus?
SimpleReview flags invoice lines for a human decision and uses context to reduce errors caused by fixed keywords. Its product terms disclaim performance guarantees, and the general AI terms warn about incomplete, biased or hallucinated output. These warnings do not describe a refusal, confidence threshold or unsupported answer route for the invoice model. The Counsel Exchange support assistant is restricted to product usage help and cannot answer questions about client data, a support boundary that says nothing about abstention in SimpleReview's billing judgments.
The product resolves simple requests on its own and routes complex ones, naming conflict waivers, intellectual property and outside counsel engagements, to the right workflow, person or practice group, and it flags the urgency of every request. The routing sorts by request complexity as the customer configures it, not by the model's confidence in its answer. Nothing describes what happens when the model cannot classify a request, misreads one, or drafts something it lacks grounds for.
No confidence score, abstention state or no answer condition is shown to the requester or the legal team. Requesters are business employees, not lawyers.
Fabricated Citation Record
Does a public court record exist addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations in output from this product?
Damien Charlotin's AI Hallucination Cases database, which held 2,262 cases on 2 November 2026, has no case naming SimpleLegal or SimpleReview. The product's main AI workflow concerns invoice narratives and financial review rather than drafting briefs or retrieving authorities, which limits what a citation incident would test. Onit's contract expressly recognizes hallucination and inaccuracy risks. A case attributed only to an unnamed AI tool cannot reliably be assigned to this product.
The AI Hallucination Cases database kept by Damien Charlotin holds no entry naming LegalWorks or Tonkean. LegalWorks routes internal requests and generates operational documents rather than legal citations.
Bar Guidance Alignment
Has the vendor engaged in public with the ethics opinions its buyers are bound by?
Onit's legal-operations community discusses verification as a professional duty, candor to courts and the risks of ungoverned AI use. Its August 2026 roundup also references cautions about agentic systems from Britain's Bar Standards Board. This is general professional-responsibility commentary, not a SimpleReview control mapping to a named ethics opinion. The customer contract separately requires review of output and disclaims legal advice.
No product-specific treatment links training permissions, client consent, billing review and supervisory procedures to the requirements of particular bar opinions across jurisdictions.
The LegalWorks page, the security page, the pricing page, the DPA and the customer terms name no bar authority, regulator, conduct rule or ethics opinion, and map no jurisdiction-specific guidance. The customer terms state that the Service provides analyses for informational purposes only and not as advice. The LegalWorks page frames its audit trail as helping preserve attorney-client privilege, a professional responsibility concept, and cites no source for that standard.
Billing and Fee Posture
Does the vendor address what happens to the bill when the work takes an hour instead of six?
SimpleLegal's core workflow is the corporate buyer's legal fee record: invoice intake, timekeeper rates, billing rules, line adjustments, approvals, allocations and payment tracking. SimpleReview evaluates narratives for billing issues, while configured workflows can reject or adjust entries under the department's rules. Approvers inspect the underlying charges and can add colleagues to the review. The fee record captures the buyer's review of billed services and payment decisions.
It does not automatically identify whether outside counsel used generative AI to produce the work described in each charge.
Efficiency claims are prominent and unattributed: 50 percent shorter cycle times, 30 employee hours saved each week, and a named legal operations endorsement mentioning millions of dollars saved. Nothing addresses what happens to a bill when work gets faster, and no record of AI assisted work by matter is described for that purpose. The buyer is an in house legal department, which pays outside counsel rather than billing a client.
The product coordinates outside counsel engagement and pulls data from billing systems, and nothing connects automated handling of a matter to what the department is billed for it.
Outside Counsel Guideline Readiness
Can a firm get this vendor through a client’s AI clause without a bespoke negotiation?
Onit's public register identifies SimpleLegal-specific subprocessors, the all-platform OpenAI service, service purposes and countries. The customer agreement and data processing addendum provide confidentiality, request-notice, objection and processing provisions, while SimpleReview's terms expose its training and benchmarking permissions. These materials support review of the service's data handling before a firm submits invoice narratives.
A dedicated client-consent package or completed mapping to an outside counsel AI clause is not supplied. Enforcement of the buyer's billing guidelines is a separate product function and does not itself establish compliance with that buyer's AI restrictions.
The Data Processing Addendum is public and ungated, and Schedule 1 lists every subprocessor with its service and country. The AI entries are Microsoft Azure for AI LLM engine services, OpenAI, LLC for AI and machine learning features and Google Cloud Platform for OCR, all in the United States and all marked opt in. The DPA can be forwarded to a counterparty and incorporates the 2021 Standard Contractual Clauses with UK and Swiss addenda.
Change notice is contractual: notice before any new subprocessor is authorized, a seven day objection window and a right to terminate. On an in house product the buyer is the client rather than the firm.
Court Disclosure Support
If a judge’s standing order requires an AI disclosure, can the product produce one?
The API exposes invoice detail and summary PDFs, approver status and account logs that can be filtered by user, time, object and actions such as adjustment, approval, rejection and export. These records preserve parts of the underlying source and human review history for financial work. They do not provide a per-output certificate naming the model version, retrieved material and human verification of each AI conclusion.
SimpleLegal's normal workflow is department administration, so a court disclosure concerning later use in legal work would still require additional information beyond its invoice and activity records.
The security page describes logs that cannot be repudiated, recording all edits to solutions and components and all processed transactions in test and production. The LegalWorks governance section commits to an audit trail of all actions and approvals, framed as supporting audit readiness and the preservation of attorney client privilege. Nothing says the log shows which requests an agent resolved on its own rather than a person, no model or version is attached to a generated document such as an NDA, and the LegalWorks and security pages describe no export route for the audit trail for a regulator, an auditor or a court. Tonkean also publishes product documentation.
The questions both sides leave open
Derived from the records above rather than written, so it cannot favor either vendor. Take these into both conversations and ask each side the same question.
- Primary Law Corpus Provenance
- Good Law Verification
- Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior
In summary
SimpleLegal
SimpleLegal is the electronic billing and matter management product in Onit's enterprise legal management line, built for corporate legal departments and their finance colleagues. Teams use it for intake templates, tasks, budgets, accruals, invoice approvals, cost allocations and vendor records, and its REST API sends approved invoices to accounts payable or an ERP. SimpleReview adds machine learning and language processing that read billing narratives and flag lines a keyword rule would miss, while configured workflows can highlight, reject or adjust entries. Instacart reports savings of about 10 percent of identified legal spend and payment to outside counsel in 15 days or less on average. According to the AI Legal Index, Onit hosts SimpleLegal on AWS in the United States and lists OpenAI among its subprocessors. The main caveat is data use: Onit's product terms let it train its AI engines on customer data.
Tonkean LegalWorks
Tonkean LegalWorks is matter lifecycle management for in house legal departments, built on Tonkean's no code process orchestration platform. Employees ask for help in Slack, Microsoft Teams, email or a branded portal. The AI Front Door answers simple questions, routes the rest into intake forms that adapt to risk and matter type, and flags urgency on every request. Agents generate NDAs and statements of work automatically, while complex matters follow approval paths and risk tiers the department sets. According to the AI Legal Index, Tonkean holds SOC 2 Type 2 and ISO/IEC 27001:2022, publishes its data processing addendum with every subprocessor, and offers multi tenant, dedicated or customer hosted deployment. The main caveat is the paper: its customer terms date from May 2019 and cap liability at three months of fees.
Questions buyers ask
How does SimpleLegal compare to Tonkean LegalWorks?
SimpleLegal manages legal spend: electronic billing, matters, vendors and AI invoice review through SimpleReview. Tonkean LegalWorks manages incoming requests: an AI Front Door, intake forms, triage and agents that handle routine NDAs and statements of work. Tonkean lists SimpleLegal among its integrations, so a department can run both. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
What do SimpleLegal and Tonkean LegalWorks cost?
Neither publishes a subscription figure. SimpleLegal quotes its subscription, includes 1 TB of storage with extra storage at $600 a month per TB, and can charge submitting law firms an annual portal fee. Tonkean quotes by monthly tracked user, averaged across the year, with multi tenant hosting included and dedicated or customer hosted options at extra cost. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Do SimpleLegal and Tonkean train AI on customer data?
Onit's product terms for SimpleLegal allow analysis, AI training and benchmarking with customer data, with shared results generally anonymized or aggregated. Tonkean's published terms and data processing addendum do not mention training, and its customer terms say Tonkean may use customer content only to run the platform. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Which AI models do SimpleLegal and Tonkean use?
For SimpleLegal, Onit's subprocessor register lists OpenAI as a platform wide provider for language generation, processed in the United States and worldwide. Tonkean's data processing addendum lists Microsoft Azure for its AI language model engine, OpenAI for AI and machine learning features and Google Cloud for OCR, each in the United States and each marked opt in. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Where do SimpleLegal and Tonkean host data?
SimpleLegal runs on Amazon Web Services in the United States, with an Australian provider converting portal PDFs. Tonkean hosts its shared cloud on AWS and also offers a dedicated cloud or hosting in a customer's own AWS, Azure or Google Cloud environment. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.
Neither vendor paid for inclusion, placement or a grade, and neither reviewed this page before it published. Everything on it comes from public material on the dates shown. How the index grades.
Neither vendor publishes an accuracy figure for its AI, whether SimpleReview's flags or Tonkean's triage and drafting. SimpleLegal publishes no standard subscription amount, portal fee table or SimpleReview usage allowance. Tonkean publishes no price figure, its customer terms date from May 2019, and no responsible AI or testing position is published for its agents.