Minesoft PatBase vs PatSnap: how they compare in 2026

M
Minesoft PatBase profile
P
PatSnap profile
Last verifiedNovember 16, 2026
Verdict

PatBase and PatSnap both search the world's patents, but they serve different moments in IP work. Minesoft's PatBase is a search and analytics platform for professional searchers, covering more than 180 million publications from over 100 issuing authorities. Its AI helps the searcher rather than replacing the search. AI Explain shows why a result surfaced, Document Chat answers questions about one patent, Smart Images reads drawing numerals, and alert classifiers learn from a user's own folders. PatSnap is an innovation intelligence platform for IP and research teams, with more than 210 million patent, science and technology records. Its Eureka agents run tasks end to end, from freedom to operate analysis to Markush claim drafting, and its Open Platform exposes the data through APIs, MCP servers and agent skills. PatSnap sells Eureka Pro online from $100 a month for 10,000 credits, while PatBase licenses named users on annual terms with prices quoted. PatBase says customer data never trains its models and keeps data on UK servers, and PatSnap publishes neither point. Searchers who want control of every query fit PatBase. Teams that want agents to draft the first analysis fit PatSnap.

Which one fits

Choose Minesoft PatBase if

  • Your searchers want to see why a result surfaced. AI Explain highlights where a query overlaps each document, and relevance scores sit beside the results.
  • Data should stay in the UK. Minesoft runs PatBase as a private cloud on UK servers and says customer data never trains its models.
  • Drawings carry the answer. Smart Images reads reference numerals in patent drawings, and Document Chat answers questions about a single patent.
  • Alerts should learn your interests. Alert classifiers can be trained in bulk from a user's own folders and search history.
  • Legal wants to read the contract first. Minesoft's subscription terms download in full without a login, with a twelve month cap on liability and a warranty that the product works as described.

Choose PatSnap if

  • You want agents to run the analysis. Eureka agents carry out freedom to operate checks, novelty assessments and Markush claim drafting.
  • Patents are only part of the picture. PatSnap's records span scientific literature, litigation records, clinical data and technical knowledge across 20 domains.
  • You want to start without a sales call. Eureka Pro costs $100 a month for 10,000 credits or $200 for 20,000, with a 14 day trial that needs no card.
  • Your own tools should reach the data. The Open Platform offers REST APIs, MCP servers, UI widgets and agent skills, with a Developer Center.
  • You want accuracy measured. PatSnap publishes PatentBench, a benchmark of real patent tasks with its methodology and results.

At a glance

Category
Minesoft PatBaseIP & Patents
PatSnapIP & Patents
Founded
Minesoft PatBase1996
PatSnap2007
Headquarters
Minesoft PatBaseRichmond-upon-Thames, London, United Kingdom
PatSnapSingapore
Last verified
Minesoft PatBaseNov 16, 2026
PatSnapNov 16, 2026

All 15 axes, side by side

The same grid applied to every vendor in the index, graded from public sources. Hover a grade to see what the letter means on that axis.

AI Centrality

How much of the product is actually AI. Whether the machine learning is the mechanism the buyer is paying for or a feature layered onto conventional software, and whether the vendor is specific about which is which.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on AI CentralityThe models are the engine of a core capability, layered on a product that would still function without them as a document or workflow system.

Most AI features date from 2025 and 2026. Document Chat answers questions about a single patent, AI Explain shows where a query overlaps a document, and Smart Images reads reference numerals in drawings. Users can also train alert classifiers, natural language queries are expanded with relevance scores, the Smart Claims viewer separates claim types, and machine translation is built in. Underneath is a platform in market since 2003 from a company founded in 1996, with a curated collection of more than 180 million publications from over 100 authorities, family level organization and daily data quality checks. Boolean, proximity, wildcard and command line searching is still sold to professional searchers. Without the models a searcher keeps the data, the family structure, the classification tools and the syntax; the AI changes who else can use it and how quickly.

PatSnap
BB on AI CentralityThe models are the engine of a core capability, layered on a product that would still function without them as a document or workflow system.

Founded in 2007, PatSnap's underlying asset is its data: more than 2 billion structured data points and over 210 million patent, science and technology records, with search, landscaping, dashboards and analytics that predate generative AI and work without it. The vendor describes Eureka as a capability layer rather than a separate platform. That layer spans agents for prior art, freedom to operate, drafting, translation and life sciences work, and the vendor describes a four stage data pipeline built to feed it. Without the models, PatSnap remains a working patent analytics business.

Citation Accuracy and Hallucination Disclosure

Whether the vendor publishes measured accuracy on citations and assertions, grounds output to primary sources, and says plainly what its system does when it does not know. Legal has a documented public record of fabricated citations reaching filed briefs, so an untested claim of accuracy is not evidence.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on Citation Accuracy and Hallucination DisclosureGrounding is real and documented, with linked primary sources and a described retrieval method, short of published accuracy figures an outsider can test.

AI Explain shows the user exactly where their input overlaps a document, highlighting the matching sections and wording, and Minesoft says the purpose is to let a searcher judge a result's relevance and see why it appeared. Relevance scores come with results, and Document Chat works on a single patent, so its answers have a bounded, visible source. No precision or recall figure is published for the AI search, no test set is described, Document Chat has no published evaluation, and no failure mode is named. Clause 11 of the agreement disclaims any warranty that the Information is accurate or complete, and says the licensor does not guarantee the accuracy of the Product or the Information or accept liability for the consequences of their use.

PatSnap
AA on Citation Accuracy and Hallucination DisclosureMeasured accuracy is published with the test set described and the failure modes named. Output grounds to primary authority the reader can open, citation status is checked, and the system states when it found no support.

PatentBench is published as a benchmark built for real patent work, measuring specific tasks against structured data, legal context and source linked evidence, with a full methodology the vendor links to. The published results are a 77 percent hit rate on design freedom to operate and a claim of being 83 times more accurate than ChatGPT on that measure. Grounding is described in the architecture: retrieval augmented generation over a governed corpus, a four stage pipeline the vendor says reduces hallucinations, and source linked evidence as a property of the benchmark. The benchmark is the vendor's own rather than independent, and the 83 times figure compares against a general purpose chatbot on a task it was not built for.

Autonomy and Oversight Model

What the system decides on its own, what a lawyer must approve, and whether the vendor documents where the review point sits. A tool that drafts under review and a tool that files without one are different products and different risks.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on Autonomy and Oversight ModelA written commitment that the models work alongside a supervising lawyer, with real review surfaces, short of the full control structure: commonly the threshold at which the system stops or what happens after it is wrong.

AI Explain lets a user see why a result surfaced, showing the overlap between query and document rather than presenting a ranking as a verdict. AI alerts can be trained in bulk from a user's own folders and search history, so the classifier deciding what reaches them is tuned by their own past judgments. Relevance scores let a searcher decide where to stop. No threshold is stated at which any feature acts without review, and nothing separates AI assisted from conventional operation although both are available. Nothing describes what happens when a Document Chat answer is wrong, and there is no published route for correcting or reporting an output. No statement says the tools support rather than replace professional judgment.

PatSnap
CC on Autonomy and Oversight ModelAutonomy is claimed and oversight is asserted without a mechanism. Human in the loop appears as a phrase rather than a described control.

The platform is described as agentic across IP and life sciences, with named agents including an FTO Agent, a lead compound agent, an Antibody Target Predictor and a Markush Claim Drafting agent. A published customer account describes completing infringement analysis for new products in hours rather than weeks. Data governance is described at each stage of the pipeline, which governs inputs rather than agent behavior. Nothing published states what an agent may complete without human review, whether any output can be relied on without verification, what confidence signal accompanies an agent result, or where a human checkpoint sits in a workflow that runs from query to report. The outputs drive decisions: a freedom to operate assessment clears a product for launch, and a novelty judgment decides whether a molecule is pursued.

Operational and Outcome Evidence

Named, dated evidence that the product works in production at real firms or legal departments. Case studies with figures and identified customers count. Unattributed testimonials and launch announcements do not.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on Operational and Outcome EvidenceCustomer logos and unattributed testimonials stand in for evidence, or results are quoted with no basis stated.

Minesoft says more than 90,000 innovators and legal professionals use the platform, that it has served patent professionals since 1996, and that PatBase launched in 2003. The data covers more than 180 million publications across over 100 authorities, support is offered in fifteen or more languages across all time zones, and a public status page is maintained. The product and feature pages name no customer, the navigation has no case study section, no testimonial is attributed to a named person or organization, and no figure is published for time saved, recall improved or cost reduced by any AI feature. Feature announcements describe benefits such as speed and less noise without measurement. A company registration number is published, which identifies the company rather than the product.

PatSnap
AA on Operational and Outcome EvidenceNamed firms or legal departments, dated, with figures for what changed and a method a reader can assess.

Named customers include NASA, Tesla, Vodafone, MIT and General Electric, reported in independent trade coverage as well as on vendor pages. NCH Corporation is also named, with Michael Schuster, VP of Product Development and Innovation, quoted by name and title. Corporate history is public: founded in 2007, a unicorn valuation in 2021 after a $300m Series E led by SoftBank Vision Fund 2 and Tencent, and Jeffrey Tiong as chief executive. Independent sources include a Gartner Peer Insights listing, a SoftwareOne marketplace listing, and a hands on review by a named trade publication that took a trial and published its assessment. The outcome claims, productivity up to 60 percent higher and workflows 90 percent faster, carry no method, and one customer quote about hundreds of thousands of dollars saved names no organization.

Privilege and Confidentiality Posture

How client confidences are handled: attorney client privilege and work product treatment, segregation of one client matter from another, whether client data trains any model, and what the vendor commits to in writing rather than in marketing.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on Privilege and Confidentiality PostureSubstantive published commitments on confidentiality and training use, short of the full picture: commonly silence on segregation between users or matters, or on what the underlying model provider may retain.

The product pages say customer data is never used to train models, that searches and results belong to the customer, and that the platform is a private cloud storing data securely under data protection law. In the agreement, clause 19 sets a mutual confidentiality duty lasting five years after termination and limits use of the other party's confidential information to performing the agreement. It also requires notice before any legally compelled disclosure where the law allows. Clause 20 commits both parties to the UK Data Protection Act 2018 and the GDPR, and clause 4 lets the customer keep an archive copy of retrieved information for twelve months after termination. Privilege and work product are not named. No model provider is identified for the generative features. No retention or deletion position covers the customer's own searches, queries or Document Chat exchanges.

PatSnap
CC on Privilege and Confidentiality PostureConfidentiality is asserted in general terms, or the commitment lives only in a sales conversation and cannot be read in advance.

PatSnap publishes strict data isolation, ISO certified security policies, encryption in transit and at rest, consent management, GDPR and CCPA compliance, and positioning as a privacy first partner for enterprises, covering the confidential research and portfolio material customers upload. Nothing mentions attorney client privilege or work product, or treats a law firm user's material as carrying professional obligations distinct from a corporate research team's. PatSnap sells across research and development, strategy, life sciences and legal, and treats confidentiality as an enterprise data question throughout.

UPL and Professional Responsibility Posture

Whether the vendor is clear that it supplies a tool rather than legal advice, who its audience is, and how it addresses unauthorized practice of law, competence and supervision duties, and jurisdiction limits. ABA Formal Opinion 512 is the reference point. Where the advice line is not the duty a product raises, the axis is read through the nearest professional duty it does raise: judicial conduct rules and the reviewing duty for products sold only to courts, and the duty to bill for time actually spent for products that draft time entries.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on UPL and Professional Responsibility PostureA boilerplate disclaimer sits in the terms while the marketing describes the product in advice terms, or the intended audience is left ambiguous.

Clause 11 supplies the Product and Information as is, disclaims any warranty that the Information is accurate or complete, and says the licensor does not guarantee accuracy or accept liability for the consequences of use. Clause 10 adds that features relying on patent office services are outside the licensor's control and that it takes no responsibility for retrieving Information. The product is marketed for freedom to operate analysis, patent due diligence and invalidity screening, all of which produce legal conclusions, to legal teams, IP experts, professional searchers and R&D teams together. Nothing addresses where the tool stops and professional judgment begins, supervision or competence, or any rule of professional conduct, and nothing covers an R&D user acting on a Document Chat answer about claim scope without counsel.

PatSnap
DD on UPL and Professional Responsibility PostureNothing published on the advice line for a product that produces legal work, including where it is sold to people who are not lawyers.

The platform generates freedom to operate assessments, novelty and design patent risk analyses, and drafts patent claims including Markush structures, outputs that a practitioner signs off or a business relies on. The published customer accounts describe research and development staff who are not lawyers using them for risk decisions. Nothing published addresses whether output is legal advice, what role qualified counsel plays where an engineer or chemist runs a freedom to operate agent directly, or any professional conduct framework. Named buyers include scientists and engineers as well as attorneys.

AI Governance and Bias Disclosure

Published governance over model behavior: who owns it inside the vendor, what is tested before release, and what is disclosed about disparate output across matter types, parties, or populations.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on AI Governance and Bias DisclosureResponsible AI principles are published without a mechanism, a testing regime, or anything a buyer could audit.

Customer data is never used to train models, processing takes place in a private cloud on UK servers, and the data centers are said to meet ISO 27001. AI Explain is presented as a transparency feature, and the autumn 2025 release grouped changes around transparency. The site has a dedicated AI section, and no AI policy or responsible AI page appears in the site navigation. Outside that section, no framework is cited, no person or body is named as accountable for model behavior, no testing before release is described and no evaluation result is published. Bias is not addressed. The alert classifier learns from a user's own past selections, and nothing published addresses the narrowing that can cause.

PatSnap
CC on AI Governance and Bias DisclosureResponsible AI principles are published without a mechanism, a testing regime, or anything a buyer could audit.

The vendor publishes that a four stage pipeline processes over 2 billion data points across 20 domains with rigorous governance at every stage, says this is what reduces hallucinations and improves reliability, and names its retrieval architecture. PatentBench is a published evaluation instrument. No AI policy, model card, bias or fairness testing, accuracy monitoring beyond the benchmark, drift statement, named governance body, ISO 42001 or EU AI Act positioning is published.

AI Safety and Data Stewardship

Retention, deletion, access control, and what happens to prompts and documents after they are processed. Whether the vendor states its subprocessors and its incident practice, or leaves the buyer to assume.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on AI Safety and Data StewardshipSubstantive published policy covering most of the ground, short of the full set: commonly no named subprocessor list or no stated incident practice.

Customer data is never used to train models, searches and results belong to the customer, and information is stored securely and privately in a private cloud on UK servers. The data centers are said to meet ISO 27001. Clause 6 of the agreement makes the customer responsible for the security of its User IDs and requires immediate notice of unauthorized use, with an audit right for the licensor on seven days' notice. Clause 19 carries a five year confidentiality tail, and clause 20 commits to the UK Data Protection Act 2018 and the GDPR. A public status page shows availability. No subprocessor list is published; RWS is named only as a translation development partner, not as a processor of customer data. No retention period or deletion commitment covers searches, queries or Document Chat exchanges. No breach notification commitment to customers is published, and the agreement puts the notification duty on the customer only.

PatSnap
CC on AI Safety and Data StewardshipA generic privacy policy covers the product without addressing what happens to documents and prompts after processing.

Strict data isolation, ISO certified security policies, encryption in transit and at rest with named protocol and cipher, GDPR and CCPA compliance with stated consent management, and a self description as privacy first are all published. Nothing is published on whether documents customers upload, search histories, proprietary formulations or research materials are used to train or improve the domain models, and no retention period or deletion right is stated. Customers upload their own novel compounds, formulations and unpublished technical material.

AI Liability and Recourse

What the vendor stands behind contractually when its output is wrong. Indemnities, caps, carve outs, insurance, and whether any of it is published or only reachable through a negotiated agreement.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on AI Liability and RecourseA real published position on liability, short of the full picture: commonly a stated indemnity without scope or caps.

The agreement can be downloaded in full without a login. Clause 11 warrants that the Product will operate materially in line with its description or technical specification, before disclaiming all other warranties. Liability is capped at the license fee paid in the preceding twelve months, with the usual exclusions for lost profits, revenue or business and for indirect, consequential, special, punitive or exemplary loss. Clause 13 requires the licensor to indemnify the customer against claims that the Product infringes a third party's intellectual property, subject to notice, control of the defense and no admissions, with a matching customer indemnity for use of the Product. Termination is for material breach with fourteen days to remedy, under English law and courts. Nothing addresses the accuracy of a generated answer or risk from a decision based on one, and no insurance position is published.

PatSnap
DD on AI Liability and RecourseNothing published on who bears the loss when the system is wrong.

No position is published on liability for AI output, warranty, service levels or remedy. The outputs feed business decisions rather than filings: a published customer account describes the FTO Agent completing infringement analysis in hours, and another describes lead compound screening as the first gate in a research process, so a false clearance sends a product to market and a false negative on novelty ends work on a viable molecule. The vendor publishes a 77 percent hit rate on design freedom to operate, which by its own arithmetic means roughly one in four is missed.

Practice Systems Integration Depth

How deeply the product reaches into the systems legal work already lives in: document management such as iManage and NetDocuments, Word and Outlook, contract lifecycle management, matter management, e-billing, and court filing systems.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on Practice Systems Integration DepthIntegrations are listed as logos or marked as coming, with no documentation an implementer could use.

A Patent Data API is sold as its own product line, and Minesoft offers separate API and MCP routes for bringing its data into a customer's own AI agents, alongside an early access program for an agentic tool. Within the suite, PatBase sits alongside Minesoft Origin, PatDocs and ChemX, and analytics output, including charts, heat maps and clusters, can be exported and shared. No connector catalog is published, no outside system is named as supported, and nothing describes how results would reach a docketing or IP management system.

PatSnap
AA on Practice Systems Integration DepthDocumented, verifiable integrations into the systems legal work already lives in, with the depth described: what syncs, in which direction, and what a firm must configure.

The Patsnap Open Platform is a dedicated developer product rather than a connector list, with four integration surfaces: REST APIs, MCP servers, UI widgets and agent skills, backed by a published Developer Center and documentation. Coverage is counted: more than 20 patent APIs, more than 25 corporate APIs and more than 16 infringement APIs. The MCP servers expose the data and its agents as tools for outside AI systems, and the vendor names the frameworks it targets, including LangChain, AutoGen and function calling workflows. An API key is available from the site, so a developer can assess, obtain and build against the platform without contacting sales. No IP management or docketing system integration is named.

Deployment Model and Data Residency

Where the software runs and where the data sits. Multi tenant cloud, single tenant, private deployment, on premises, and whether region of residence is a published option or an enterprise conversation.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on Deployment Model and Data ResidencyDeployment model is stated clearly with partial residency detail, or residency is offered without the processing location being addressed, or the tenancy model is stated on its own with no residency detail published.

Minesoft states repeatedly that its servers are in the United Kingdom, offered as a reason customer data is secure. The platform is described as a private cloud in which a customer's searches and results are its own, and the 2020 rebuild as a cloud move led by RWS for resilience and security. Data centers are said to meet ISO 27001. No deployment options are offered or refused, so nothing says whether single tenant, private or on premise arrangements are available, and no other region is offered. Nothing explains how customers are kept separate in the private cloud, and no data center operator is named.

PatSnap
DD on Deployment Model and Data ResidencyNothing published on where the software runs or where client data sits.

No hosting provider is named, no region or residency commitment is published, and no single tenant, dedicated or on premises option is described. The company is headquartered in Singapore, names SoftBank and Tencent among its investors and serves customers including NASA, MIT and General Electric, and nothing published says where research material and unpublished technical data are processed. Stated GDPR and CCPA compliance does not say where data sits.

Security Certifications and Trust Center

Independent attestation a buyer can pull without a sales call: SOC 2, ISO 27001, penetration test summaries, a trust center with current reports and named scope rather than a badge image.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on Security Certifications and Trust CenterBadges appear on the site with no scope, no date, and no report available.

The disclosure is one sentence: Minesoft's security commitment is backed by ISO 27001 certification, ensuring its data centers meet international information security standards. Read strictly, that attaches the certification to the data centers rather than to Minesoft's own security management system, and nothing says which is meant. No certificate number, certification body, issue or expiry date, scope statement or route to obtain the certificate or a report is published, and there is no trust center or security documentation page. The published practices are the private cloud, the UK server location, and the User ID security and audit terms in clause 6 of the agreement.

PatSnap
BB on Security Certifications and Trust CenterCertification is real and stated, short of accessible evidence: a named standard without scope, date, or a way to obtain the report.

PatSnap holds an AICPA attestation and ISO 27001:2022 certification, with annual external audits, TLS 1.3 and AES-256 encryption in transit and at rest, GDPR and CCPA compliance, and consent management, all set out on its trust center. The SOC attestation is described as SOC 2 Type 1, which assesses the design of controls at a single point in time rather than their operation over a period. No auditing firm is named, and no certificate date is given for the ISO certification.

Model Supply Chain Disclosure

Which models sit underneath, whose they are, where they run, and whether the vendor commits to telling customers when that changes. A legal buyer inherits every dependency it cannot see.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on Model Supply Chain DisclosureThe vendor refers to advanced or proprietary models without identifying what sits underneath.

Seven AI features are named: Document Chat, AI Explain, Smart Images, the trainable alert classifier, natural language query expansion with relevance scores, the Smart Claims viewer and machine translation. No model, version or architecture is given beyond references to image recognition and claim recognition, and no provider is named for the generative feature, Document Chat, where a third party foundation model would usually sit. Nothing says where inference runs relative to the UK servers, what any provider keeps of a Document Chat question, or whether customers would be told of a model change, and clause 10 of the agreement reserves the right to change the Product and its features without notice. RWS, which develops the platform with Minesoft, provides machine translation and is said to be improving it continuously; that disclosure covers translation only.

PatSnap
DD on Model Supply Chain DisclosureNothing published about the model supply chain a customer inherits.

No foundation model provider, model family or version is named, and no subprocessor list is published. The vendor describes its architecture in technical terms, naming retrieval augmented generation and what it calls retrieval augmented thinking, and describes domain specific and domain trained models, which describe method rather than provenance. An independent product review notes an evolving AI backbone, so the underlying models change over time. The Open Platform exposes the agents built on those models to external systems through MCP servers.

Commercial Transparency

Whether a buyer can learn what this costs without entering a sales process: published rates, the unit being charged, what sits behind an enterprise tier, and what implementation adds.

Minesoft PatBase
CC on Commercial TransparencyPricing is gated behind a demo request while tier names and feature splits are published, so the shape is visible and the number is not.

The agreement publishes the unit and structure of charging. Licensing is per User ID, and extra User IDs can be added on written request, ending with the existing term and charged pro rata from the month added. The term is twelve months unless the Product Terms say otherwise, renewing automatically for one year periods unless either party gives thirty days' written notice. Invoicing is annual in advance. Late payment carries interest at eight percent above the Bank of England base rate plus collection costs, and the licensor may suspend access without notice while payment is outstanding. Clause 17 says Product Terms prevail over the general Terms in a conflict, so the commercial specifics live there. No price, band, minimum or range is published, and the only route is a demonstration request.

PatSnap
BB on Commercial TransparencyReal pricing is published for part of the range, with enterprise tiers withheld, or the unit and structure are stated without the figure.

Figures are published for the self serve plans. Eureka Pro is priced by monthly credits, at $100 a month for 10,000 credits and $200 a month for 20,000, with larger bundles above. The materials science Pro plan is listed at $200 a month and the life sciences Pro plan at $400 a month, each with a discount for yearly billing. Two self serve entry points exist: a 14 day free trial of Eureka with 10,000 credits and an API key from the Open Platform with usage based pricing. Enterprise plans and the Analytics Standard and Premium plans carry no figure, and those routes end in a demo or quote request. An independent analyst platform describes a named Enterprise plan that includes agents such as the Antibody Target Predictor and Markush Claim Drafting.

Firm and Practice Coverage

Who the product is actually built for. AmLaw, midlaw, small firm and solo, in house departments, government and courts, and which practice areas are supported rather than merely claimed.

Minesoft PatBase
BB on Firm and Practice CoverageSegment and practice coverage is described with substance, short of the boundaries: what is supported is clear, what is not is left open.

Minesoft cites more than 180 million publications from over 100 issuing authorities, full text for the major jurisdictions, family and publication level organization, and a live feed with daily quality checks. Machine translation, often available the same day as a new document, covers languages for cross border prior art. A spring 2026 release added fourteen standards bodies for standard essential patent work by name, IEEE, ISO, CCSA, OMA, IMT, OneM2M, TIA, ATIS, ITU-T, ITU-R, IEC, IETF, ANSI and TTA, with dedicated search syntax. Named use cases span search, monitoring, collaboration, due diligence, freedom to operate, competitor intelligence and technology landscaping. They are aimed at IP experts, legal teams, R&D teams and professional searchers, with support in fifteen or more languages. No jurisdiction is identified as thinly covered, no technology area as better or worse served, and no coverage dates or backfile depth are given.

PatSnap
AA on Firm and Practice CoverageWho the product serves is documented precisely: firm segments, in house and government use, and the practice areas actually supported, with the limits stated.

Scale is stated as more than 2 billion structured data points and over 210 million patent, science and technology records, spanning patents, scientific literature, litigation records, clinical data and technical knowledge across 20 domains, so coverage extends beyond patents to other prior art. Industries are listed: agriculture and chemicals, consumer goods, food and drink, life sciences, automotive, oil and gas, professional services, aviation and aerospace, and education. Life sciences capabilities are named for sequences, Markush structures, structure activity relationship extraction, clinical trial comparison and druggability. Patent translation trained on global patent data supports work across jurisdictions. No update lag or refresh frequency is published, and no list of patent offices is given.

The 12 legal signals, side by side

Recorded rather than graded. These are the questions a practitioner has to answer before a tool touches a client matter, and the answers are taken from public material only.

Client Data in Training

Can material a lawyer puts into this product be used to train a model?

Minesoft PatBase
Never, in policy only

More than one product page states, in the same words and without qualification, that Minesoft never uses customer data to train models and that a customer's searches and results are their own, kept in a private cloud. The UK and International Annual Subscription Terms are published without a login and contain no training provision either way. Clause 3 vests intellectual property in the licensor and its suppliers, clause 4 grants the customer its license to use and archive Information, clause 19 sets mutual confidentiality with a five year tail, and clause 20 commits both parties to the UK Data Protection Act 2018 and the GDPR. The commitment is a published policy, not a contract term.

PatSnap
Terms silent

The quoted phrase is the closest the vendor comes to addressing customer content in the AI context, and it describes isolation and compliance rather than use. The Eureka pages, home page, life sciences landing page, trust center summary and Open Platform material say nothing in either direction about whether documents customers upload, proprietary formulations, search histories or research materials are used to train or improve the domain models.

Customers upload novel compounds, unpublished technical material and internal documents for analysis, and the vendor separately markets models trained across 20 domains. The trust center holds further material behind its gate.

Prompt and Output Retention

How long does the product keep what a lawyer typed, and can that be set to zero?

Minesoft PatBase
Not addressed

The agreement deals with retention only the other way round. Clause 4(b) lets the customer keep an archive copy of Information from the platform for up to twelve months after the agreement ends, and clause 5.1 forbids holding it as a searchable database or sharing it outside without written permission and extra fees. The product pages say searches and results belong to the customer and are held securely in a private cloud.

Neither the agreement nor the product pages state a retention period for the customer's searches, queries or generated answers, a deletion right, or what happens to search history when a subscription ends. Users are invited to train alert classifiers from their folders and search history, so the history is kept at least long enough to be training input.

PatSnap
Not addressed

No retention period is published for uploaded documents, agent queries, generated reports or analysis outputs, and nothing indicates whether retention can be configured or whether a customer can require deletion. Consent management is named as a capability, but it concerns the collection of personal data under GDPR and CCPA rather than how long uploaded research material is held. Customers upload unpublished research material and proprietary formulations for analysis.

Ethical Walls and Matter Segregation

Does retrieval respect the firm’s ethical walls, or can the model read across them?

Minesoft PatBase
Claimed, not documented

The product pages describe a private cloud in which a customer's searches and results are its own, which addresses separation between customers. In the agreement, access runs through individually issued User IDs. Clause 5(e) forbids use of a User ID by anyone not employed by the customer, and clause 6 makes the customer responsible for User ID security and requires immediate notice of unauthorized use, with an audit right for the licensor on seven days' notice.

Nothing describes control of access between users. No roles or administrator functions are described, and nothing says whether one user's saved work, folders, search history or alerts are visible to colleagues on the same subscription.

PatSnap
Claimed, not documented

The vendor states strict data isolation alongside ISO certified security policies and consent management. Nothing says whether isolation operates between customers, between users in an organization or between projects, or how the boundary applies when an agent runs analysis across the data. The platform is sold to research and development, strategy and legal teams in the same enterprise, and to competing enterprises in the same technical field, and nothing published says what prevents one customer's uploaded formulation or unpublished compound from informing anything shown to another. No integration with a customer permission system is described.

Third Party Request and Subpoena Notice

If someone subpoenas the vendor for a firm’s data, does the firm hear about it first?

Minesoft PatBase
Notice committed

Clause 19 of the published agreement sets a mutual confidentiality duty, limits each party's use of the other's confidential information to performing the agreement, and deals with compulsion directly. A party may disclose as required by law or by a government or regulatory authority, but must, where legally permitted, give the other party as much notice as possible. The duty lasts for the term and five years after. It is mutual, so it binds Minesoft in the customer's favor, and it gives the customer time to seek a protective order or narrow the demand.

There is no commitment to challenge a demand or redirect it to the customer, no minimum notice period and no transparency report. The duty covers confidential information generally rather than customer data specifically.

PatSnap
Not addressed

No government or law enforcement request clause, no commitment to notify a customer before producing their data, and no transparency report appear on the trust center summary, the home page, the Eureka pages or the site navigation. The company is headquartered in Singapore with named investors including SoftBank Vision Fund 2 and Tencent, its named customers include NASA, MIT and General Electric, and customers upload unpublished technical material.

Primary Law Corpus Provenance

Where does the law in this product come from, and does the vendor have the right to use it?

Minesoft PatBase
Sources named, basis unstated

Minesoft describes more than 180 million publications from over 100 patent authorities, with full text for major jurisdictions delivered through a live feed of what it calls quality patent sources, checked daily. For standard essential patent work, fourteen standards bodies are named as sources: IEEE, ISO, CCSA, OMA, IMT, OneM2M, TIA, ATIS, ITU-T, ITU-R, IEC, IETF, ANSI and TTA, each with its own search syntax. Machine translation is attributed to RWS.

No license or data supply arrangement is described for any source, no individual patent office is named, and no coverage dates or backfile depth are given. Clause 10 of the agreement says some features depend on public patent services from patent offices or other third parties and disclaims responsibility for their quality or availability.

PatSnap
Sources named, basis unstated

The data is listed as more than 2 billion structured data points and over 210 million patent, science and technology records, spanning patents, scientific literature, litigation records, clinical data and technical knowledge across 20 domains, processed through a four stage pipeline described as applying governance at every stage. Patent documents are published by offices as a condition of grant, but scientific literature is largely copyrighted and clinical trial data is licensed or regulated, and nothing states what rights support their inclusion, from which publishers or registries, or on what terms. No update lag, refresh frequency or historical date range is published.

Good Law Verification

Does the product tell you when the authority it just cited has been overruled?

Minesoft PatBase
Licensed citator, surfaced inline

On a patent platform, the equivalent of a good law check is whether a right is still in force. Legal status updates come from the issuing authorities and are shown inside each record alongside bibliographic, full text and family data, so a searcher can see a result's standing without leaving PatBase, and family level organization lets status be read across a family. Clause 10 of the agreement says features rely on public patent services provided by patent offices or other third parties, that changes to them are outside the licensor's control, and that it takes no responsibility for their quality.

Nothing says how often legal status is refreshed or how quickly an authority's change appears. The platform adds no status prediction or confidence indicator of its own.

PatSnap
Not addressed

The platform performs freedom to operate analysis, design patent risk assessment, infringement risk identification and novelty assessment, all of which turn on the legal status of the references surfaced: whether a patent is granted and in force, lapsed for unpaid fees, expired, amended in reexamination, or invalidated after grant. A freedom to operate clearance that treats a lapsed patent as a live blocking right, or misses one that has been revived, gives the wrong answer.

Nothing published states whether legal status is tracked, surfaced or used in risk scoring. Litigation records are named as part of the data, with no statement that outcomes are linked back to the patents they concern.

Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior

What does the product do when the answer is not in the corpus?

Minesoft PatBase
Confidence signal only

Results carry relevance scores, described as helping users prioritize, and the AI is said to learn what matters to each user. AI Explain shows which sections and wording of a document overlap the query, so a searcher can see the basis of a score, not only its size. No threshold is stated below which a result is withheld or flagged, nothing says what Document Chat does when a question cannot be answered from the patent, nothing indicates when Smart Images fails to resolve a reference numeral, and the platform never reports that it does not know. A relevance score covers only the results that appear, not a relevant document that never appears.

PatSnap
Not addressed

PatentBench gives a 77 percent hit rate on design freedom to operate, which describes performance in aggregate and says nothing about the result in front of a user. No confidence indication accompanies an agent output, and no flag marks a weak match. Nothing says whether an FTO Agent will report that it could not reach a conclusion rather than returning one, or what a user sees when the data does not support an answer. A 77 percent hit rate means roughly one in four is missed, and nothing tells the user which.

Fabricated Citation Record

Does a public court record exist addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations in output from this product?

Minesoft PatBase
None located

The AI Hallucination Cases database kept by Damien Charlotin holds no entry naming Minesoft or PatBase. PatBase retrieves patent documents from curated authority feeds rather than generating citations to legal authority, and Document Chat answers questions about a patent already in front of the user.

PatSnap
None located

The AI Hallucination Cases database kept by Damien Charlotin holds no entry naming PatSnap or Eureka. The platform produces analyses and reports that support business decisions rather than documents filed at a patent office.

Bar Guidance Alignment

Has the vendor engaged in public with the ethics opinions its buyers are bound by?

Minesoft PatBase
Not addressed

The agreement and the product, search, analytics and release pages name no bar association, rule of professional conduct, ethics opinion, patent office code of conduct or regulator, in the UK, the US, Germany or anywhere else Minesoft operates. The agreement has no condition asking the customer to use the platform consistently with its professional duties, and the product pages do not say the tools support rather than replace professional judgment.

The platform is sold for freedom to operate analysis, invalidity screening and due diligence to legal and R&D teams together. Patent practice has its own professional rules, including the duty to disclose material prior art, and nothing on the site connects the product to that duty or any other.

PatSnap
Not addressed

No named ethics opinion, USPTO Rules of Professional Conduct reference, 37 CFR citation or bar guidance from any jurisdiction appears on the home page, the Eureka pages, the life sciences landing page or the site navigation. PatSnap sells across research and development, strategy, life sciences and legal, most of its named customers are corporations rather than law firms, and its material speaks to enterprise buyers. The platform generates freedom to operate assessments and drafts claims, and legal is a named buyer.

Billing and Fee Posture

Does the vendor address what happens to the bill when the work takes an hour instead of six?

Minesoft PatBase
Not addressed

Nothing published addresses what happens to the bill when AI assisted work takes an hour instead of six. Minesoft sells to law firms, says it helps patent professionals win back time, and markets its AI on speed and less noise, while prior art searching is usually billed to clients as practitioner time or a disbursement. No record of AI assisted searching by matter is described. Nothing marks a result set or Document Chat answer as machine generated for a search report or fee narrative, and no guidance covers passing search cost to a client.

The agreement publishes the commercial terms between Minesoft and the customer, such as per User ID licensing and annual invoicing, which concern what the customer pays Minesoft, not what the customer's client is told or charged.

PatSnap
Savings claims only

The efficiency claims are productivity up to 60 percent higher and workflows 90 percent faster. A customer quote says the platform has saved hundreds of thousands of dollars when evaluating partnerships and acquisitions, a claim about avoided transaction cost rather than hours, and another describes infringement analysis moving from weeks to hours. None carries a method, baseline or period, and the six figure saving names no organization.

No position is published on how AI assisted analysis should be recorded where a firm bills a client for freedom to operate work, and no exportable record shows what share of an assessment was machine generated.

Outside Counsel Guideline Readiness

Can a firm get this vendor through a client’s AI clause without a bespoke negotiation?

Minesoft PatBase
Not addressed

The UK and International Annual Subscription Terms can be downloaded without a login and forwarded to a client. They cover mutual confidentiality with a five year tail, notice before any legally compelled disclosure where the law allows, compliance with the UK Data Protection Act 2018 and the GDPR, and a vendor indemnity against third party intellectual property claims. No subprocessor list or data processing addendum is published; clause 20 commits to data protection law without naming any processor.

No model provider is named for any of the seven AI features. RWS is named as a development partner, not as a processor of customer data.

PatSnap
On request only

The trust center is a defined destination that lists AICPA certification, SOC 2 Type 1, ISO 27001:2022 with stated annual external audits, TLS 1.3 and AES-256 encryption, GDPR and CCPA compliance, strict data isolation and consent management. Outside its gate, nothing is downloadable, and no subprocessor list, named model provider, data processing agreement, named auditor, certificate date or route to the SOC report itself is published. The SOC report is Type 1, which covers control design at a point in time rather than operation over a period.

Court Disclosure Support

If a judge’s standing order requires an AI disclosure, can the product produce one?

Minesoft PatBase
Not addressed

AI Explain shows which sections and wording of a document matched a query as a view in the interface, not as a record that persists and travels. Search history is kept long enough to train alert classifiers, and analytics output such as charts, heat maps and clusters can be exported and shared. No search report template is offered, nothing marks an exported result set as AI expanded rather than Boolean, and no export of the AI Explain overlap is described.

No guidance says whether AI use should be recorded or disclosed to a patent office, an opposing party in invalidity proceedings or a client questioning a search.

PatSnap
Partial record

Source linked evidence is named as a property of the PatentBench methodology, and the platform runs on a governed corpus with a four stage pipeline, so an assertion in a generated report can be traced to a document. The Open Platform exposes the underlying data through APIs, so a claim can be queried again against the same data without the vendor's cooperation. Nothing indicates that output records which model or agent produced it, and an independent review describes an evolving AI backbone, so the system behind an older report may not be the one running today. No record of human verification is captured.

What neither one publishes

The questions both sides leave open

Derived from the records above rather than written, so it cannot favor either vendor. Take these into both conversations and ask each side the same question.

Signals neither addresses in public material
  • Prompt and Output Retention
  • Bar Guidance Alignment
Change log

Product updates

The latest logged changes from each vendor, newest first, each linked to its source.

PatSnap

  • Privilege / confidentiality

    PatSnap moved the OpenAI, Claude and Gemini model deployments used by its EU data center environments to EU regions supported by those providers during the week of 2 November 2026.

    Source
  • Integration / interoperability

    Patsnap made its Life Sciences and Patent MCP servers available inside EMET, BenchSci's agentic research environment for preclinical drug discovery.

    Source
All 2 PatSnap updates →

In summary

Minesoft PatBase

Minesoft PatBase is a global patent search and analytics platform used by more than 90,000 IP, legal and research professionals for prior art searching, freedom to operate work, portfolio management, competitor monitoring and landscapes. It covers more than 180 million patent publications from over 100 issuing authorities, organized by family, with machine translation often available the same day. Its AI features, most added in 2025 and 2026, include AI Explain, Document Chat, Smart Images for drawing numerals, trainable alert classifiers and natural language query expansion with relevance scores. According to the AI Legal Index, Minesoft says customer data never trains its models and runs the platform as a private cloud on UK servers. The main caveat is price: licenses are per named user on twelve month terms, and the figures sit in Product Terms that are not published.

Source: AI Legal Index, 2026

PatSnap

PatSnap, founded in 2007 and headquartered in Singapore, is an innovation intelligence platform for IP teams, research and development groups and innovation leaders. It draws on more than 2 billion structured data points and over 210 million patent, science and technology records. Its Eureka agents handle freedom to operate analysis, novelty checks, design patent risk and Markush claim drafting, and the Open Platform exposes the data through REST APIs, MCP servers, widgets and agent skills. Named customers include NASA, Tesla, Vodafone and MIT. According to the AI Legal Index, PatSnap publishes PatentBench, a benchmark of patent tasks with its methodology, and holds ISO 27001:2022 and a SOC 2 Type 1 attestation. The main caveat is data: no training position, hosting region or model provider is published.

Source: AI Legal Index, 2026

Questions buyers ask

How does PatBase compare to PatSnap?

PatBase is a patent search and analytics platform for professional searchers, with AI that explains results, answers questions about a patent and reads drawings. PatSnap is a broader innovation intelligence platform whose Eureka agents run freedom to operate, novelty and claim drafting tasks over patents and scientific data. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.

What do PatBase and PatSnap cost?

PatSnap publishes self serve prices: Eureka Pro at $100 a month for 10,000 credits or $200 for 20,000, with materials and life sciences Pro plans at $200 and $400 a month and enterprise plans by demo. PatBase licenses named users on twelve month terms that renew automatically, and its prices are quoted. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.

Do PatBase and PatSnap train AI on customer searches?

Minesoft says on its PatBase product pages that customer data is never used to train models and that searches and results belong to the customer. PatSnap describes strict data isolation and privacy controls but publishes no statement either way on training. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.

How do PatBase and PatSnap show patent status?

PatBase shows legal status from the issuing authorities inside each record, beside bibliographic, full text and family data. PatSnap's agents produce freedom to operate and infringement risk analyses, but it does not describe how legal status is sourced or shown. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.

Where do PatBase and PatSnap host data?

Minesoft runs PatBase as a private cloud on UK servers in ISO 27001 data centers. PatSnap, headquartered in Singapore, names no hosting provider or region. From the AI Legal Index, based on each vendor's own published materials as of November 16, 2026. No vendor pays for placement.

Disclosure

Neither vendor paid for inclusion, placement or a grade, and neither reviewed this page before it published. Everything on it comes from public material on the dates shown. How the index grades.

Neither vendor names the models behind its AI features. PatBase's prices sit in Product Terms that are not published, and its ISO 27001 certification attaches to its data centers rather than to Minesoft. PatSnap publishes no hosting region, training position, retention period or terms on liability for agent output.

Contact

Correct a record, or ask how something was graded

Every grade and every signal on this index is drawn from public sources and dated. If a record is wrong, out of date, or missing an artifact the index did not locate, send the source and it will be reviewed and the record redated. Vendors are welcome to submit documentation. Nothing on this index is for sale, including a listing, a placement, or a grade.

AI Legal Index

The AI Legal Index is an independent index that tracks changes to AI vendors in legal. It holds 535 vendors across 9 categories, each graded on the same 15 capability axes and recorded against 12 legal signals, from public sources. No vendor pays for inclusion, placement, or rating.

Index Status
Last index update
November 19, 2026
The AI Legal Index is an editorial reference. It is not a regulatory body, not a law firm, and nothing published here is legal advice or a recommendation to retain or avoid a vendor. Records are verified against published sources, bar guidance and public court records. Where a record reads not addressed, the material was not located in public sources on the date shown. See the Methodology page for evaluation standards and limitations.
© 2026 AI Legal Index
3801 N Capital of Texas Hwy, Ste E240 · Austin, TX 78746