B
Black Hills AI

Black Hills AI makes intellectual property software and provides docketing and paralegal support for patent and trademark practices. The Minneapolis company was founded by intellectual property attorneys in 2009. OttoFlow combines a rules-based docket with AI document classification, verification queues, prosecution summaries and analysis of office actions. Each computed date can be traced to its rule and source document.

The company sells a full software license and a standalone license for Information Disclosure Statement management. SureDocket places selected docketing work into a customer's existing system, and DualDocket provides an independent check alongside it. Otto IP adds patent drafting and review in the browser and in Microsoft Word. Otto HUB connects the tools to Patent Center and other sources and offers built-in summary and analysis.

Black Hills says its engines have completed more than five million fully automated docketing transactions and names Zimmer Biomet, Dickinson Wright and Schwegman Lundberg among the organizations that trust it. Patent annuity processing is offered through an affiliated company. OttoFlow can run on a firm's own AI-provider credentials. The standard terms restrict model training on client materials, require review of AI output and allow an executed agreement to control customer-specific terms.

Capability grades

All 15 axes, graded from public sources on the date shown. Hover a grade to see what the letter means on that axis.

BB on AI CentralityThe models are the engine of a core capability, layered on a product that would still function without them as a document or workflow system.

AI Centrality

How much of the product is actually AI. Whether the machine learning is the mechanism the buyer is paying for or a feature layered onto conventional software, and whether the vendor is specific about which is which.

OttoFlow uses AI to read incoming documents, extract office-action information, summarize prosecution and run readiness checks. Built-in analysis can trigger workflow tasks, draft response shells and flag exceptions. Deadlines themselves come from a versioned rules engine that applies the same procedure when the inputs are the same. Otto IP adds generation in the browser and Word, and Otto HUB supplies first-party analysis as well as an external-assistant connection. The embedded AI is used in the core workflow alongside conventional calculations and an optional staff service.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Citation Accuracy and Hallucination DisclosureGrounding is real and documented, with linked primary sources and a described retrieval method, short of published accuracy figures an outsider can test.

Citation Accuracy and Hallucination Disclosure

Whether the vendor publishes measured accuracy on citations and assertions, grounds output to primary sources, and says plainly what its system does when it does not know. Legal has a documented public record of fabricated citations reaching filed briefs, so an untested claim of accuracy is not evidence.

The docket captures the source document, formula, rule version and reviewer behind a deadline. OttoFlow flags AI-sourced values in a verification queue and public materials show how staff inspect the record. Those controls let a user trace a result. The company advertises a broad accuracy advantage over general AI without an independently reproduced error series that isolates the generative features. Public materials give no validated rate for unsupported patent citations, extraction errors or omitted prosecution documents in the AI console.

Source: Vendor Published
AA on Autonomy and Oversight ModelWhat the system runs alone, what constrains it, and how a lawyer checks it are all published: modes, thresholds, review surfaces, and the route a matter takes back to human judgment. A categorical limit on a named mode or tier, stating what its output may not be used for, meets the threshold limb without a number.

Autonomy and Oversight Model

What the system decides on its own, what a lawyer must approve, and whether the vendor documents where the review point sits. A tool that drafts under review and a tool that files without one are different products and different risks.

The workflow starts when a patent office document triggers a procedure. A model can run against the file, claims and current record, and an exception is sent for human review. The docket and audit trail capture what the system did and identify the user who confirmed it. Writes through an outside assistant are validated against matter, obligation, rules and user access. The standard terms require confirmation before relying on deadline-critical output. The split between software and staff review can also be defined in the executed agreement.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Operational and Outcome EvidenceReal deployment evidence with substance, short of full attribution or measurement: a named customer without figures, or figures without the named customer.

Operational and Outcome Evidence

Named, dated evidence that the product works in production at real firms or legal departments. Case studies with figures and identified customers count. Unattributed testimonials and launch announcements do not.

The company names Zimmer Biomet, Dickinson Wright and Schwegman Lundberg, and describes a Decipher IP integration for independent docket checks, annuities and patent-file histories. It reports more than five million fully automated docketing transactions and over 95% automation coverage. These are company figures for the broader engine, with no firm-level starting error rate or controlled comparison isolating the AI layer.

Public presentations explain integration and testing of docketing workflows. They provide few measurements of named clients' results with the current OttoFlow features.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Privilege and Confidentiality PostureSubstantive published commitments on confidentiality and training use, short of the full picture: commonly silence on segregation between users or matters, or on what the underlying model provider may retain.

Privilege and Confidentiality Posture

How client confidences are handled: attorney client privilege and work product treatment, segregation of one client matter from another, whether client data trains any model, and what the vendor commits to in writing rather than in marketing.

Standard terms give mutual confidentiality with a service-purpose restriction and restrict model training on client materials. The service uses customer-provided intellectual property files and data to perform the work. OttoFlow enforces row-level tenant isolation and checks permissions on assistant writes. Model processing in the vendor-managed environment is described as zero retention, while buyer-chosen model providers run under customer arrangements.

The security and contract materials identify safeguards for confidential records. They do not state a privilege preservation obligation or how disclosure to a specific outside model affects a matter.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on UPL and Professional Responsibility PostureA real position is published on advice versus tooling, short of full treatment: commonly a disclaimer without the supervision and competence dimension, or silence on jurisdiction limits.

UPL and Professional Responsibility Posture

Whether the vendor is clear that it supplies a tool rather than legal advice, who its audience is, and how it addresses unauthorized practice of law, competence and supervision duties, and jurisdiction limits. ABA Formal Opinion 512 is the reference point. Where the advice line is not the duty a product raises, the axis is read through the nearest professional duty it does raise: judicial conduct rules and the reviewing duty for products sold only to courts, and the duty to bill for time actually spent for products that draft time entries.

The terms distinguish legal support and software from legal advice and give responsibility for final filings and deadline verification to the customer. AI-generated or AI-assisted deadlines require confirmation by the customer or by Black Hills personnel under the executed agreement. The company offers domestic docketing and paralegal staff and tools built by patent attorneys. Its professional education material addresses competence and independent judgment in AI use.

Public terms do not promise attorney representation or supervise an individual partner's legal opinion or filing strategy.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on AI Governance and Bias DisclosureA published governance framework with real substance, short of testing results or a named owner.

AI Governance and Bias Disclosure

Published governance over model behavior: who owns it inside the vendor, what is tested before release, and what is disclosed about disparate output across matter types, parties, or populations.

Administrators can enable each of eleven OttoFlow AI features by tenant, use model overrides and apply per-user spending and rate limits. A usage view identifies who used a feature and the charge. AI-created work can be traced to the action and reviewer. The company documents deterministic rules for deadline calculations and a verification queue for flagged model-sourced items. Public materials leave model-release evaluation thresholds, systematic bias testing across jurisdictions or languages, and an independent review of AI governance undisclosed.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on AI Safety and Data StewardshipSubstantive published policy covering most of the ground, short of the full set: commonly no named subprocessor list or no stated incident practice.

AI Safety and Data Stewardship

Retention, deletion, access control, and what happens to prompts and documents after they are processed. Whether the vendor states its subprocessors and its incident practice, or leaves the buyer to assume.

The standard terms restrict training and provide notice of compelled disclosure when legally permitted. The security materials describe domestic hosting, encryption, access controls and closed AI processing with zero model retention. A firm can choose to run OttoFlow features on its own AI-provider credentials. Its provider agreement determines retention on that external route. Docket history and draft material can persist within the platform.

A public subprocessor schedule, fixed workspace prompt deletion period and data return procedure beyond the transition language in the terms were not identified.

Source: Vendor Published
CC on AI Liability and RecourseLiability is addressed only through a standard limitation clause that disclaims the exposure the product creates.

AI Liability and Recourse

What the vendor stands behind contractually when its output is wrong. Indemnities, caps, carve outs, insurance, and whether any of it is published or only reachable through a negotiated agreement.

The standard terms cap claims at fees paid for the affected service in the prior 12 months and exclude loss, lapse, abandonment or invalidity of an intellectual property right. Customers indemnify Black Hills for specified categories, and executed agreements can supersede the standard terms. The provisions call for cooperation on data and pending renewals at termination, subject to transition fees. There is no public vendor indemnity or warranty for missed docketing dates or inaccurate AI work. Mandatory legal liabilities remain subject to applicable law.

Source: Vendor Published
AA on Practice Systems Integration DepthDocumented, verifiable integrations into the systems legal work already lives in, with the depth described: what syncs, in which direction, and what a firm must configure.

Practice Systems Integration Depth

How deeply the product reaches into the systems legal work already lives in: document management such as iManage and NetDocuments, Word and Outlook, contract lifecycle management, matter management, e-billing, and court filing systems.

Otto HUB connects to Patent Center and draws on Global Dossier, EPO Open Patent Services, WIPO and other offices. It can cross-reference records in an existing IP management system and connect to document management. A scoped Agent API supports writes, event notifications and document pushes. Microsoft Word integration and configured connections to external AI assistants add additional entry points. The Decipher IP partnership describes a concrete integration for docket checks, annuity tracking and publication file histories. The platform can also produce time and billing data with LEDES and UTBMS.

Source: Vendor Published
AA on Deployment Model and Data ResidencyDeployment options and data residency are published, including the regions available, what changes between tiers, and where processing happens as distinct from where data is stored.

Deployment Model and Data Residency

Where the software runs and where the data sits. Multi tenant cloud, single tenant, private deployment, on premises, and whether region of residence is a published option or an enterprise conversation.

OttoFlow runs on Amazon Web Services and offers a pinned region and dedicated account boundary. The security center states that Black Hills infrastructure, servers and support are in the United States. The platform documents database-level tenant isolation and use of customer AI-provider credentials. The location of inference under that option follows the customer's supplier arrangement. The combination identifies application residency and a dedicated deployment boundary.

Outside the standard domestic environment, the terms and provider setup determine which locations and account configurations are available to a particular customer.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Security Certifications and Trust CenterCertification is real and stated, short of accessible evidence: a named standard without scope, date, or a way to obtain the report.

Security Certifications and Trust Center

Independent attestation a buyer can pull without a sales call: SOC 2, ISO 27001, penetration test summaries, a trust center with current reports and named scope rather than a badge image.

OttoFlow describes PostgreSQL row-level isolation, multifactor authentication, single sign-on, encryption and an append-only security audit stream. Its enterprise materials offer SOC 2 auditing, incident response and business continuity documentation under a nondisclosure agreement. The public security center describes employee checks, change management and risk assessment. A public SOC 2 report or certification with auditor, reporting period and workload scope is unavailable.

The documentation request route can establish whether the relevant software and service boundaries appear in the applicable report.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Model Supply Chain DisclosureThe supply chain is partly disclosed: providers named without change notification, or architecture described without the providers.

Model Supply Chain Disclosure

Which models sit underneath, whose they are, where they run, and whether the vendor commits to telling customers when that changes. A legal buyer inherits every dependency it cannot see.

OttoFlow can run all of its enabled AI features under a firm's own provider account. Its administrator can set model overrides by feature and encrypt credentials separately. Claude, ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot are named connection targets for the assistant connector. Those names identify tools a customer can connect. The vendor-hosted Otto IP and Otto HUB features disclose zero-retention APIs, with no public line-by-line list of models or versions for those workloads. Customer-supplied inference and vendor-managed processing follow distinct arrangements.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Commercial TransparencyReal pricing is published for part of the range, with enterprise tiers withheld, or the unit and structure are stated without the figure.

Commercial Transparency

Whether a buyer can learn what this costs without entering a sales process: published rates, the unit being charged, what sits behind an enterprise tier, and what implementation adds.

OttoFlow is licensed as a full platform or as the smaller Information Disclosure Statement manager. SureDocket and DualDocket use subscriptions, and OttoFlow meters AI use by feature on the customer's provider account. The public terms say executed agreements can set specific charges, scope and payment terms. No dollar entry price is displayed for docketing or OttoFlow. The affiliated renewals operation uses a per-payment management fee. Transition fees can apply when an engagement ends, with the actual amount available by agreement.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Firm and Practice CoverageSegment and practice coverage is described with substance, short of the boundaries: what is supported is clear, what is not is left open.

Firm and Practice Coverage

Who the product is actually built for. AmLaw, midlaw, small firm and solo, in house departments, government and courts, and which practice areas are supported rather than merely claimed.

The software is aimed at law firms and corporate intellectual property groups. Its published rule library covers 1,853 procedures in 63 rule sets, including utility and design patents, national phase, European and international applications, utility models and trademarks. The workflow includes prosecution, information disclosure statements, proofing and client reporting. Honu connects more than 300 foreign agents according to Black Hills, and an affiliated service handles patent annuities.

The practice scope stays within intellectual property rather than providing a general workflow for litigation, employment or transactions.

Source: Vendor Published
Sources on file

6 public documents

The public pages on file for Black Hills AI, with the recorded signals each one supports and the date it was last read. Open any of them and check the reading against the record.

Pricing

No published figure

  • OttoFlow is quoted as a full platform or as a standalone Information Disclosure Statement manager. SureDocket and DualDocket use subscriptions. OttoFlow meters built-in AI features under the customer's model-provider account. The affiliated renewals service separately uses a per-payment management fee.

Quote by license or docketing service, with metered model usage

Implementation: Quoted, with possible transition fees at termination

Note: The product offers a demonstration and specifies the license and service options. The standard terms defer customer-level charges and payments to the executed agreement.

Legal Signals

What each signal means

A signal records what public sources say on the date shown. It is not a grade and it is not a recommendation. Where a signal reads Not addressed, it means the index did not locate the material in public sources on that date, which is a statement about disclosure rather than about the product.

Confidentiality and Privilege

Client Data in Training

Can material a lawyer puts into this product be used to train a model?

Never, in the contract

The published terms prohibit training on customer content. Not a policy page, the agreement.

The standard terms say client materials are excluded from training the vendor's AI models. Executed agreements can supersede the terms. OttoFlow users who connect their own AI provider operate under their own provider terms.

Source: Vendor PublishedClient Materials are not used to train our AI models.As of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Prompt and Output Retention

How long does the product keep what a lawyer typed, and can that be set to zero?

Disclosed without a period

Retention is acknowledged in public materials with no stated period.

The security materials state zero retention for closed AI processing. The workspace maintains draft, verification and audit records, and the firm can connect a separate provider. The public materials do not give a workspace prompt and output schedule.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Ethical Walls and Matter Segregation

Does retrieval respect the firm’s ethical walls, or can the model read across them?

Own model, documented

The product maintains its own permission model, documented, requiring the firm to keep it aligned.

OttoFlow enforces database-level tenant isolation and validates assistant writes against matter, rules and user permissions. Its public materials do not establish how it inherits a connected firm's ethical walls during retrieval.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Third Party Request and Subpoena Notice

If someone subpoenas the vendor for a firm’s data, does the firm hear about it first?

Notice committed

Terms commit to notice where lawfully permitted. No transparency report located.

The terms require notice to the disclosing party where legally permitted for a disclosure required by law.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence
Accuracy and Authority

Primary Law Corpus Provenance

Where does the law in this product come from, and does the vendor have the right to use it?

Sources named, basis unstated

Sources are identified without stating the license or rights basis.

Patent Center, Global Dossier, EPO Open Patent Services, WIPO and other offices are named sources. The platform combines their records with prior art and customer files. The full rights basis for that material is undisclosed.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Good Law Verification

Does the product tell you when the authority it just cited has been overruled?

Prompts the user to verify

The product instructs the reader to check the citation without performing the check.

The terms require review of results and deadline confirmation. The software receives official docket events and calculates due dates. It does not describe a general good-law check for the legal authorities in AI drafting.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior

What does the product do when the answer is not in the corpus?

Documented

The vendor describes refusal or abstention behavior in public materials.

Uncertain docketing, AI-sourced data and failed readiness checks can reach a named verification workflow. The product does not give an explicit no-answer protocol for missing legal authority.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Fabricated Citation Record

Does a public court record exist addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations in output from this product?

None located

No court order, opinion or disciplinary record addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations produced by this product has been located as of the date shown. This is a statement about the public record on that one subject, not a finding about the product, and this signal is not a litigation history.

No public fabricated-citation finding attributed to the Black Hills AI products was identified in the materials reviewed.

Source: Operator VerifiedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence
Professional Responsibility

Bar Guidance Alignment

Has the vendor engaged in public with the ethics opinions its buyers are bound by?

Generic reference

Public materials refer to professional responsibility in general terms without naming guidance.

The company's attorney education deck addresses named ABA Model Rules on competence and independent judgment. It does not map product controls to a named bar ethics opinion.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Billing and Fee Posture

Does the vendor address what happens to the bill when the work takes an hour instead of six?

Audit record only

A usable record of AI assisted work exists with no published fee guidance.

OttoFlow attributes AI writes to a user and reviewer and traces changes to the matter, and it can produce billing data with LEDES and UTBMS. The public offer does not explain how firms should bill clients for AI-assisted time.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Outside Counsel Guideline Readiness

Can a firm get this vendor through a client’s AI clause without a bespoke negotiation?

On request only

The material exists behind a sales conversation or an executed agreement.

OttoFlow offers security and incident response documentation under a nondisclosure agreement. The standard terms provide for customer-specific data protection obligations in an executed agreement.

Source: Vendor PublishedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence

Court Disclosure Support

If a judge’s standing order requires an AI disclosure, can the product produce one?

Not addressed

No located public material addresses court disclosure or verification certification.

The audit trail captures activities, sources and reviewer actions in prosecution workflows. No published product workflow provides a court AI disclosure or certification export.

Source: Operator VerifiedAs of Nov 19, 2026Evidence
Contact

Correct a record, or ask how something was graded

Every grade and every signal on this index is drawn from public sources and dated. If a record is wrong, out of date, or missing an artifact the index did not locate, send the source and it will be reviewed and the record redated. Vendors are welcome to submit documentation. Nothing on this index is for sale, including a listing, a placement, or a grade.

AI Legal Index

The AI Legal Index is an independent index that tracks changes to AI vendors in legal. It holds 535 vendors across 9 categories, each graded on the same 15 capability axes and recorded against 12 legal signals, from public sources. No vendor pays for inclusion, placement, or rating.

Index Status
Last index update
November 19, 2026
The AI Legal Index is an editorial reference. It is not a regulatory body, not a law firm, and nothing published here is legal advice or a recommendation to retain or avoid a vendor. Records are verified against published sources, bar guidance and public court records. Where a record reads not addressed, the material was not located in public sources on the date shown. See the Methodology page for evaluation standards and limitations.
© 2026 AI Legal Index
3801 N Capital of Texas Hwy, Ste E240 · Austin, TX 78746