L
Legal Twin Smart Legal Research

Legal Twin Smart Legal Research is an AI agent for German case law, sold by STP, the Karlsruhe legal software house that is part of Septeo, as a browser subscription beside its Advoware practice system. A lawyer asks a legal question in plain German or pastes a short summary of the facts, and the agent finds semantically similar decisions in STP's collection of German court rulings. Each answer links the judgments behind it, which open in full as text or PDF, and the agent can compare lines of argument across similar cases, assess the chances of an argument and propose wording for a submission.

Each user's chats are private to that user, who can archive or delete them. In Advoware, firms that also license Legal Twin Case Knowledge can run the research from an analyzed matter, so questions are answered against that file. An MCP server lets assistants such as Claude retrieve matching decisions with a relevance value and the closest passage.

The four packages, S, M, L and Unlimited, cost €9.90, €15, €20 and €30 a month before VAT on a 12 month term, with message allowances shared across the firm and a 14 day free trial with the Advoware offer. Brockmeier, Faulhaber and Rudolph, a Westphalian firm of seven lawyers, uses it inside Advoware.

Capability grades

All 15 axes, graded from public sources on the date shown. Hover a grade to see what the letter means on that axis.

AA on AI CentralityThe artificial intelligence is the product. Remove the models and there is nothing left to sell.

AI Centrality

How much of the product is actually AI. Whether the machine learning is the mechanism the buyer is paying for or a feature layered onto conventional software, and whether the vendor is specific about which is which.

Smart Legal Research is sold as an AI agent: a lawyer writes a question or a summary of the facts, and the model finds semantically similar German decisions, writes the answer, compares the arguments that succeeded and proposes wording for a submission. The decisions themselves are reached only through those answers, since the subscription has no separate keyword index or browse view. Without the models there is no retrieval and no answer, and only the archive of earlier chats would remain.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Citation Accuracy and Hallucination DisclosureGrounding is real and documented, with linked primary sources and a described retrieval method, short of published accuracy figures an outsider can test.

Citation Accuracy and Hallucination Disclosure

Whether the vendor publishes measured accuracy on citations and assertions, grounds output to primary sources, and says plainly what its system does when it does not know. Legal has a documented public record of fabricated citations reaching filed briefs, so an untested claim of accuracy is not evidence.

Answers link each judgment they rely on, and the full decision opens as text or PDF from the chat. Retrieval is semantic: the question or fact summary is matched against STP's collection of German court decisions, and each match comes back with a relevance value and the passage that fits best, six results above a 0.3 similarity threshold by default. The 90% time saving offered for finding case law and building strategy has no method behind it, and no test shows how often a controlling decision is missed.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Autonomy and Oversight ModelA written commitment that the models work alongside a supervising lawyer, with real review surfaces, short of the full control structure: commonly the threshold at which the system stops or what happens after it is wrong.

Autonomy and Oversight Model

What the system decides on its own, what a lawyer must approve, and whether the vendor documents where the review point sits. A tool that drafts under review and a tool that files without one are different products and different risks.

The agent answers each question on its own, and the lawyer works from the linked decisions it returns. In Advoware the lawyer decides when to start the research with Juristische Recherche starten, and only after the matter has been analyzed. Results are suggestions inside a chat, and nothing reaches a filing or the file unless the lawyer copies it there. Retrieval returns six decisions by default above a 0.3 similarity cutoff, which limits the decisions that come back but not what the chat writes when none clears it.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Operational and Outcome EvidenceReal deployment evidence with substance, short of full attribution or measurement: a named customer without figures, or figures without the named customer.

Operational and Outcome Evidence

Named, dated evidence that the product works in production at real firms or legal departments. Case studies with figures and identified customers count. Unattributed testimonials and launch announcements do not.

Brockmeier, Faulhaber and Rudolph, a Westphalian practice with seven lawyers including three notaries and 25 staff, uses the research agent inside Advoware alongside Case Knowledge, so lawyers stay in the matter while finding rulings. Its account describes easier daily access to case law without a time or quality measure. Four beta testimonials on the product page carry first names and initials only, and the 90% time saving comes without a sample or period.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Privilege and Confidentiality PostureSubstantive published commitments on confidentiality and training use, short of the full picture: commonly silence on segregation between users or matters, or on what the underlying model provider may retain.

Privilege and Confidentiality Posture

How client confidences are handled: attorney client privilege and work product treatment, segregation of one client matter from another, whether client data trains any model, and what the vendor commits to in writing rather than in marketing.

Each lawyer's research chats are visible only to that user, not to colleagues in the firm. STP's general conditions limit use and disclosure of confidential information to the agreed purposes, extend confidentiality to employees and agents after termination, and provide a separate confidentiality agreement under section 43e BRAO and section 26a BNotO for lawyers and notaries. Hosted use requires a data processing agreement. No term covers what the model provider keeps from a question or bars training on research questions.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on UPL and Professional Responsibility PostureA real position is published on advice versus tooling, short of full treatment: commonly a disclaimer without the supervision and competence dimension, or silence on jurisdiction limits.

UPL and Professional Responsibility Posture

Whether the vendor is clear that it supplies a tool rather than legal advice, who its audience is, and how it addresses unauthorized practice of law, competence and supervision duties, and jurisdiction limits. ABA Formal Opinion 512 is the reference point. Where the advice line is not the duty a product raises, the axis is read through the nearest professional duty it does raise: judicial conduct rules and the reviewing duty for products sold only to courts, and the duty to bill for time actually spent for products that draft time entries.

Lawyers frame the question, open the linked decisions and decide what goes into a submission, so the product stays a research tool. Its assessments of likely success and its suggested wording stay suggestions in the chat. The general conditions provide for a confidentiality agreement under German lawyer and notary rules, and the product is offered for work under professional secrecy. No guidance covers how a lawyer should supervise the success assessments or disclose AI use to a court.

Source: Vendor Published
CC on AI Governance and Bias DisclosureResponsible AI principles are published without a mechanism, a testing regime, or anything a buyer could audit.

AI Governance and Bias Disclosure

Published governance over model behavior: who owns it inside the vendor, what is tested before release, and what is disclosed about disparate output across matter types, parties, or populations.

STP presents the agent as fully compliant with the GDPR, professional secrecy and the EU AI Act, and every answer rests on German judgments. Its parent's ISO 27001 certificate covers research services among other lines. Retrieval works to a similarity threshold, 0.3 on a scale of 0 to 1 by default in the MCP server. No named owner for the models, release testing or review of uneven results across courts, areas of law or types of litigant stands behind the compliance claim.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on AI Safety and Data StewardshipSubstantive published policy covering most of the ground, short of the full set: commonly no named subprocessor list or no stated incident practice.

AI Safety and Data Stewardship

Retention, deletion, access control, and what happens to prompts and documents after they are processed. Whether the vendor states its subprocessors and its incident practice, or leaves the buyer to assume.

Each user is assigned to the research entitlement by name in STP Cloud user management, where the firm's administrator also manages rights. Chats are visible only to the user who started them; archived chats stay readable but cannot return to the active list, and deleted chats cannot be recovered. Hosted use requires a data processing agreement under the general conditions, which also bind employees and agents to confidentiality beyond the end of the contract. No subprocessor list, purge window for deleted chats or backups, or breach notice timeline applies to the subscription.

Source: Vendor Published
CC on AI Liability and RecourseLiability is addressed only through a standard limitation clause that disclaims the exposure the product creates.

AI Liability and Recourse

What the vendor stands behind contractually when its output is wrong. Indemnities, caps, carve outs, insurance, and whether any of it is published or only reachable through a negotiated agreement.

STP's general software conditions govern the subscription. Liability for ordinary negligence applies only to breaches of essential contractual duties and is limited to foreseeable loss. Software liability is capped at €500,000 per incident and €1,000,000 in total. The supplier controls the defense of third party rights claims over the software. No clause covers loss from a wrong match, a missed controlling decision or an argument the agent proposed, and no warranty attaches to the answers.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Practice Systems Integration DepthReal integrations exist and are documented, short of depth: named connections without a description of what they actually move.

Practice Systems Integration Depth

How deeply the product reaches into the systems legal work already lives in: document management such as iManage and NetDocuments, Word and Outlook, contract lifecycle management, matter management, e-billing, and court filing systems.

Two connections are documented. In Advoware, firms that also license Legal Twin Case Knowledge connect their Advoware database with the firm ID, database name and the user's Advoware abbreviation and OnlineDienste password; once a matter is analyzed, Juristische Recherche starten answers research questions against that file in the taskbar chat. An MCP server in STP Cloud, under the lt.slr.mcp2 scope and an STP.Identity client registration, gives assistants such as Claude one tool for matching decisions.

The research reaches the matter only through Case Knowledge, and its answers stay in the chat rather than moving into the Advoware file.

Source: Vendor Published
CC on Deployment Model and Data ResidencyCloud delivery is implied and neither the tenancy model nor the region is stated.

Deployment Model and Data Residency

Where the software runs and where the data sits. Multi tenant cloud, single tenant, private deployment, on premises, and whether region of residence is a published option or an enterprise conversation.

The subscription runs in the browser from the STP Cloud dashboard once the user sets a password from the welcome email, and in Advoware's taskbar for firms that connect Case Knowledge. Data travels encrypted to STP's hosted service. Neither the country of the data centers nor where the language model processes a question is stated, no tenancy model is described, and there is no private or on premises option.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Security Certifications and Trust CenterCertification is real and stated, short of accessible evidence: a named standard without scope, date, or a way to obtain the report.

Security Certifications and Trust Center

Independent attestation a buyer can pull without a sales call: SOC 2, ISO 27001, penetration test summaries, a trust center with current reports and named scope rather than a badge image.

DQS certifies the information security management system of STP Holding GmbH to ISO 27001:2022 through September 5, 2028, with a scope that includes legal technology software services and portals, research services and data licensing across the listed sites. The certificate itself is reachable as a PDF. It is an organizational certificate rather than a report on the agent and its model operations, and STP runs no trust center with audit reports. Data moves encrypted, and user rights are managed in STP Cloud.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Model Supply Chain DisclosureThe supply chain is partly disclosed: providers named without change notification, or architecture described without the providers.

Model Supply Chain Disclosure

Which models sit underneath, whose they are, where they run, and whether the vendor commits to telling customers when that changes. A legal buyer inherits every dependency it cannot see.

The architecture is described: a question is matched by semantic similarity against STP's own database of German decisions, and the closest passages feed the generated answer. In the Legal Twin settings that host the research chats, firms choose among several large language models, with Claude Sonnet as the default and experimental models on some licenses. The MCP server hands the decision, relevance value and passage to an outside assistant such as Claude. STP makes no commitment on where the models run or on notice before a model changes.

Source: Vendor Published
AA on Commercial TransparencyA buyer can learn what this costs without entering a sales process: published rates, the unit being charged, and what implementation adds.

Commercial Transparency

Whether a buyer can learn what this costs without entering a sales process: published rates, the unit being charged, what sits behind an enterprise tier, and what implementation adds.

All four packages are priced on the STP marketplace: S €9.90, M €15, L €20 and Unlimited €30 a month before VAT, each on a 12 month term billed monthly and ordered online. S, M and L carry monthly message allowances counted across the whole firm, with the balance shown at the top of the research chat, and Unlimited removes the cap. A 14 day free trial comes with the Advoware offer, there is no separate setup fee, and users are provisioned through STP Cloud from a welcome email.

Source: Vendor Published
BB on Firm and Practice CoverageSegment and practice coverage is described with substance, short of the boundaries: what is supported is clear, what is not is left open.

Firm and Practice Coverage

Who the product is actually built for. AmLaw, midlaw, small firm and solo, in house departments, government and courts, and which practice areas are supported rather than merely claimed.

Lawyers working on German law use it for anything from a specific legal question to a comparison of similar fact patterns and draft wording for a submission. Its collection holds rulings from German courts and nothing from other countries. Brockmeier, Faulhaber and Rudolph, a Westphalian firm with civil, criminal and administrative work alongside notarial practice, uses it inside Advoware, while the browser account serves firms on other practice systems. How deeply the collection covers particular courts, years or areas of law is not broken down.

Source: Vendor Published
Sources on file

5 public documents

The public pages on file for Legal Twin Smart Legal Research, with the recorded signals each one supports and the date it was last read. Open any of them and check the reading against the record.

Pricing

From €9.90/month plus VAT

EUR, as published, never converted
  • S costs €9.90 a month before VAT.
  • M is €15, L €20 and Unlimited €30 a month before VAT.
  • Each package runs 12 months, billed monthly, with message allowances shared across the firm.

Four packages are ordered on the STP marketplace. S, M and L carry monthly research message allowances counted across all users and shown at the top of the chat, and Unlimited lifts the cap. Firms wanting a larger allowance go through sales. A 14 day free trial is offered with the Advoware integration.

Implementation: Access comes through STP Cloud after a welcome email, with no setup fee for the browser account. Use inside Advoware needs a Legal Twin Case Knowledge license and its database connection.

Note: The 12 month subscription is billed monthly, and STP's general conditions renew it annually unless it is terminated within the notice period.

Legal Signals

What each signal means

A signal records what public sources say on the date shown. It is not a grade and it is not a recommendation. Where a signal reads Not addressed, it means the index did not locate the material in public sources on that date, which is a statement about disclosure rather than about the product.

Confidentiality and Privilege

Client Data in Training

Can material a lawyer puts into this product be used to train a model?

Purpose limited, in the contract

The customer agreement or data processing addendum contractually limits use of Customer Data to providing the contracted service, and no surface names training either way. The limit is bound, which a policy page is not, but it is not an express training prohibition. If any surface names training in either direction, one of the other values is true and this one is not.

STP may use and disclose confidential information only for the agreed purposes under its general conditions, and hosted use runs under a processing agreement. No clause speaks to training a model on research questions.

Source: Vendor Publishedausschließlich im Rahmen der vereinbarten ZweckeAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Prompt and Output Retention

How long does the product keep what a lawyer typed, and can that be set to zero?

Disclosed without a period

Retention is acknowledged in public materials with no stated period.

Chats stay until the user deletes them. Archived chats cannot return to the active list and deleted chats cannot be recovered, but no period governs backups or the model provider's copy.

Source: Vendor Publishedan archieved conversation can’t be unarchievedAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Ethical Walls and Matter Segregation

Does retrieval respect the firm’s ethical walls, or can the model read across them?

Claimed, not documented

Segregation is asserted in public materials with no published detail on how it is enforced.

Each user's research chats are visible only to that user. In Advoware the chat follows the matter selected there, but no rule ties research access to Advoware's own matter permissions.

Source: Vendor Publishedonly visible to you and not to any other user in the law firmAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Third Party Request and Subpoena Notice

If someone subpoenas the vendor for a firm’s data, does the firm hear about it first?

Notice committed

Terms commit to notice where lawfully permitted. No transparency report located.

Where compelled disclosure is permitted and possible, STP's conditions require advance notice to the other party so it has a chance to object.

Source: Vendor PublishedSoweit zulässig und möglichAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence
Accuracy and Authority

Primary Law Corpus Provenance

Where does the law in this product come from, and does the vendor have the right to use it?

Jurisdictions only

Coverage is described by jurisdiction with no identification of the underlying corpus.

Retrieval runs over STP's own database of German court rulings, presented as covering every German court. No list of courts, date ranges or licensing sources comes with the collection.

Source: Vendor Publishedour own database of German court rulingsAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Good Law Verification

Does the product tell you when the authority it just cited has been overruled?

Not addressed

No located public material addresses whether authority is checked for subsequent history.

Answers link the judgment itself, which opens as text or PDF. No citator or treatment status shows whether a later decision has overruled or limited it.

Source: Vendor Publishednavigate directly to the respective judgmentAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Refusal and Uncertainty Behavior

What does the product do when the answer is not in the corpus?

Confidence signal only

The product exposes a confidence or grounding score without an explicit abstention path.

Retrieval keeps only decisions above a similarity threshold, 0.3 by default, and returns a relevance value with each. The cutoff governs which decisions come back, not what the chat writes when none clears it.

Source: Vendor PublishedÄhnlichkeitsschwellenwertAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Fabricated Citation Record

Does a public court record exist addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations in output from this product?

None located

No court order, opinion or disciplinary record addressing fabricated or hallucinated legal citations produced by this product has been located as of the date shown. This is a statement about the public record on that one subject, not a finding about the product, and this signal is not a litigation history.

Answers link German decisions from STP's own collection, and no court decision in the AI Hallucination Cases database names the product.

Source: Bar Guidance or Court RecordAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence
Professional Responsibility

Bar Guidance Alignment

Has the vendor engaged in public with the ethics opinions its buyers are bound by?

Named guidance addressed

Public materials engage with at least one named ethics opinion.

STP's conditions offer a confidentiality agreement under section 43e BRAO and section 26a BNotO where lawyers and notaries need one. No bar or chamber guidance on AI use is mapped to the research workflow.

Source: Vendor Published§43e BRAO und § 26a BNotOAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Billing and Fee Posture

Does the vendor address what happens to the bill when the work takes an hour instead of six?

Outside the fee relationship

The product does not touch a fee between a lawyer and a client. It operates before an engagement exists, or it is bought by a team that bills no client for the work. Savings claims aimed at the buyer’s own cost are recorded in the summary and do not make the row a savings claim, because no client bill is in the loop.

The firm pays for a research package by the month, with message allowances counted across all its users. Nothing in the product records time or fees billed to a client.

Source: Vendor Publishedreflect the values of all users in your law firmAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Outside Counsel Guideline Readiness

Can a firm get this vendor through a client’s AI clause without a bespoke negotiation?

On request only

The material exists behind a sales conversation or an executed agreement.

Hosted use requires a data processing agreement, and a professional secrecy agreement is available where needed. No subprocessor list or security pack is offered for the research subscription itself.

Source: Vendor PublishedEs ist zwingend eine AuftragsverarbeitungsvereinbarungAs of Nov 21, 2026Evidence

Court Disclosure Support

If a judge’s standing order requires an AI disclosure, can the product produce one?

Partial record

Some elements of the record are available, short of a document level export.

Archived chats keep the question, the answer and the linked decisions, which open as text or PDF. Nothing in the product produces a statement of AI use for a court, which stays with the lawyer.

Source: Vendor PublishedYou can still access the archived chat histories.As of Nov 21, 2026Evidence
Contact

Correct a record, or ask how something was graded

Every grade and every signal on this index is drawn from public sources and dated. If a record is wrong, out of date, or missing an artifact the index did not locate, send the source and it will be reviewed and the record redated. Vendors are welcome to submit documentation. Nothing on this index is for sale, including a listing, a placement, or a grade.

AI Legal Index

The AI Legal Index is an independent index that tracks changes to AI vendors in legal. It holds 670 vendors across 9 categories, each graded on the same 15 capability axes and recorded against 12 legal signals, from public sources. No vendor pays for inclusion, placement, or rating.

Index Status
Last index update
November 21, 2026
The AI Legal Index is an editorial reference. It is not a regulatory body, not a law firm, and nothing published here is legal advice or a recommendation to retain or avoid a vendor. Records are verified against published sources, bar guidance and public court records. Where a record reads not addressed, the material was not located in public sources on the date shown. See the Methodology page for evaluation standards and limitations.
© 2026 AI Legal Index
3801 N Capital of Texas Hwy, Ste E240 · Austin, TX 78746